Super Mario Bros. Wonder keeps rewriting its own levels but rarely tests you
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A familiar run and jump that keeps getting interrupted
At its core, Wonder plays like classic Mario. You run to the end of a side-scrolling level, stomp Goombas, dodge Piranha Plants and drop through Warp Pipes. You can pick from twelve characters, including Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach, Princess Daisy, Toadette, Nabbit and four kinds of Yoshi.
The new power-ups change how you move. A fruit turns your character into an elephant. A flower lets you blow bubbles that trap enemies. A mushroom gives you a drill hat for burrowing into the floor or ceiling to slip past enemies and obstacles.
The Wonder Flower is the big addition. Touch one and the level stops behaving: pipes come alive, hordes of enemies pour in, or your character's look and abilities change. The effect lasts until you grab a Wonder Seed or leave the area. Critics agreed this is the game's best idea. IGN liked how the effects changed stages "in both surprising and delightful ways," and Eurogamer called the game "an endless cascade of ideas." GameSpot was the main dissenter, pointing to "occasional repetition" in some effects.
Badges let you set the difficulty level by level
You earn badges as you play and equip one before each level. They come in three types:
- Action Badges add a new move.
- Boost Badges give a passive bonus.
- Expert Badges grant an advanced skill.
Only one badge works at a time, and they're mostly optional, so you can play without any to make things harder. GameSpot liked how they let you match your setup "to the task at hand," and Tom's Guide said they can completely change how a level plays. This is the system that keeps the game working for newer players and series veterans alike.
The bosses and the difficulty are the weak spots
Even the warmest reviews had two complaints. Nintendo World Report called the boss fights "mostly uncreative." It pointed to airship endings that ask you to hit a switch, and said enemy attack patterns barely change from fight to fight. The same outlet said the difficulty curve stays "fairly low," so the game sometimes feels more like a ride than a platforming challenge.
Edge agreed that courses run short and the difficulty is close to easy. It still called those flaws "a price worth paying" for how energetic the game is. Most critics landed in the same place.
If you want a punishing 2D platformer, look elsewhere. If you want one that keeps surprising you, this is it.
The Nintendo Switch 2 edition, Meetup in Bellabel Park, goes after both problems. It adds Koopaling fights with their own Wonder Flower transformations, plus extra challenges for more variety and difficulty. It also adds Rosalina, Co-Star Luma (playable with the Joy-Con 2's mouse controls) and a flower pot power-up that fires flower platforms upward. Critics' one warning: much of its new content is multiplayer-only minigames, which do little for solo players.
Co-op and online play give it a long life
Up to twelve players can share a room locally, with four active in a level at a time. Online, you can see faint versions of up to three other players running the same stage. If one of them is nearby when you're defeated, you come back as a ghost and get a short window to revive by flying to them or to a standee they've placed.
Critics counted this toward the game's replay value. Tom's Guide said the local and online multiplayer would keep players coming back after the story ends, and Nintendo Life praised local co-op for the same reason. Wonder Seeds in every stage give completionists more to chase.
The presentation drew few complaints. Retro Gamer's Darran Jones could have done without the new talking flower, and called it a minor issue. The game earned honorable mentions for Game of the Year, Best Design and Best Visual Art at the 24th Game Developers Choice Awards.
On Metacritic, the original Switch release earned "universal acclaim" and the Switch 2 edition "generally favorable" reviews. OpenCritic shows 98% of critics recommending the Switch version and 88% the Switch 2 one. Nintendo Life's PJ O'Reilly called it "the best 2D Mario game since Super Mario World." Its critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 9.2 out of 10.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Super Mario Bros. Wonder en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q119819453 wikidata.org