Analysis · Super Mario Galaxy 2

Super Mario Galaxy 2 keeps the old rules and spends everything on its levels

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A sequel that bets everything on its levels

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is built on one idea: keep the first game's rules and put the effort into new places to use them. The Escapist's Susan Arendt said it "doesn't tinker" much with the formula, and most critics counted that as a strength. Mario still runs and spins across small 3D planets grouped into galaxies. He still collects Power Stars to reach later levels and still uses the Star Pointer to gather Star Bits and shoot them at enemies.

The structure is what changes. Instead of open wandering, a map of seven worlds is reached from Starship Mario, a mobile planet that works as the hub and grows as the game goes on. There are forty-nine galaxies. Each of the first six worlds ends with a fight against Bowser or Bowser Jr., and there are 242 Power Stars in all. Luigi becomes playable later, but you never have to use him.

Where the bet pays off: levels that keep changing

Most galaxies are built around one task with its own theme, and many of them change while you play. In some, gravity flips or platforms appear and vanish to the beat of the music. Others give you a switch that slows time for a short spell.

Critics praised this more than anything else. Giant Bomb's Ryan Davis said the designers were "bolder" than on the first game and more willing to take strange risks. Wired's Chris Kohler wrote that the level ideas alone could have been full games. GameSpot's Tom McShea gave it a perfect 10 and called it a "new standard for platformers", and Edge also gave it full marks.

The aggregates agree. The game holds 97% at GameRankings and 98/100 at Metacritic, which puts it among the highest-rated games on both sites. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 9.4 out of 10. In December 2010 IGN named it the number 1 Wii game, ahead of its predecessor, and in March 2012 Official Nintendo Magazine called it the greatest Nintendo game ever made.

The extra challenge cuts both ways

Prankster Comets return, but you now earn each one by finding a Comet Medal in its galaxy. The first game had five separate comet types. Here the challenges can be combined:

  • defeat every enemy
  • collect 100 Purple Coins
  • finish before a timer runs out
  • finish with only one unit of health
  • stay ahead of Cosmic Clones that copy your moves

Collect all 120 Power Stars and 120 Green Star missions open up. These hide stars in hard-to-reach spots, where one slip can mean instant death.

Critics disagreed about this. Game Informer's Matt Helgeson worried that some late challenges could feel "frustrating", and GamePro's Ben PerLee warned that the higher skill bar might turn new fans off. Worthplaying's Chris DeAngelus disagreed, writing that deaths almost always feel like player error rather than bad design.

The first 120 stars are the game most critics praised. The second 120 are for players who want precision more than anything else.

What sticking to the formula leaves out

Critics named two costs of keeping the formula. The first is the story, which hardly shows up. McShea said the best thing about it is that it "mostly stays in the background". Kohler understood that the choice kept the focus on play, but called it a waste of the storytelling skill the Mario team had shown in the first Galaxy.

The second cost is familiarity. Official Nintendo Magazine's Chris Scullion named it the "new best game on Wii" but said it didn't hit as hard as the original. He also admitted that bar was nearly impossible to clear, given how good the first game was. If you've played Super Mario Galaxy, the basic run, jump and spin will feel known from the first minute. The surprises come from the level ideas, not from new controls.

For most critics, that trade was the point. GameTrailers said the game has something great for just about everyone. X-Play's Andrew Pfister gave it 5/5 and saw it as the culmination of 20 years of Mario games.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet