Analysis · Super Mario Galaxy

Super Mario Galaxy turns tiny planets into the best Mario since 64

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for players who missed Super Mario 64

Super Mario Galaxy is Nintendo's 2007 Wii platformer, made for players who grew up on Super Mario 64 and wanted its open, star-collecting structure taken somewhere new. Mario keeps the long jump, wall jumps and somersaults from that game. The ground under him is what changes. Each level is a cluster of small planets and asteroids, and every one has its own gravity. Mario can run all the way around a planetoid, upside down, then jump off and fall toward the next one.

The structure will feel familiar. A spaceship hub, the Comet Observatory, has six domes that lead to most of the game's 42 galaxies. You earn Power Stars by finishing missions, beating bosses or reaching a set spot, and new galaxies open as your star count grows. Five of the domes end in a fight with Bowser or Bowser Jr. for a Grand Star, which opens the next dome.

Critics said it gives that player nearly everything. It holds 97 out of 100 on Metacritic from 73 reviews, which made it the fourth-highest-rated game of all time on that site. The critic average, calculated from those critic numbers, is 9.7.

Gravity makes every galaxy feel new

The shifting gravity drew more praise than any other mechanic. Jeremy Parish of 1UP.com wrote that it makes even the wildest challenge feel "almost second nature." Andrew Robinson of Computer and Video Games said the changing pull lets levels reach "genuinely draw-dropping proportions," and Margaret Robertson of Eurogamer called it an "explosion of inventiveness."

Critics also liked the pacing. Famitsu called the tempo "abnormally good" and said the level ideas and difficulty build up gradually. Alex Navarro of GameSpot rated the level design "top flight in every regard" and said the power-up suits added a "great dimension." Some sections flatten the action onto a 2D plane, and side quests such as surfing on a manta ray or rolling a giant ball through an obstacle course break up the platforming.

The Wii Remote earns its place

You play with the Wii Remote and Nunchuk. Pointing at the screen brings up the Star Pointer, a small blue cursor that collects Star Bits. You can fire them to stun enemies or feed Hungry Lumas, and the cursor can also grab Pull Stars that drag Mario through space. A shake of the remote triggers the Spin, which attacks enemies, climbs vines, unscrews bolts and fires Mario across space from Launch Stars.

Critics expected a gimmick and mostly didn't find one. Chris Scullion of the Official Nintendo Magazine admitted he doubted the pointer at first, then wrote that within minutes it felt as if he'd been using it since Mario 64. Edge said the controls were subtler than the "vigorous literalism" of The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess. Bryn Williams of GameSpy called the setup "pinpoint accurate," and Play's David Halverson said it was hard to imagine playing it any other way.

The music won over critics who came for the graphics

The visuals got the most praise of anything in the game. Matt Casamassina of IGN thought it was the only game that really pushed the Wii, and Navarro wrote that "there simply isn't a better-looking Wii game available." Some reviewers liked the music even more. Parish rated the orchestral score above the visuals, Casamassina called it the best music in any Nintendo game to date, and Williams predicted it would "go down in history."

Several critics ranked the soundtrack among the best ever written for a game, and none of the critics cited here complained about it.

Where it falls short

The complaints are real, but critics didn't think they were serious:

  • Co-op is thin. Williams called the two-player mode "shallow" and said it added nothing to the game.
  • Not every visual is a leap. Andrew Reiner of Game Informer liked the water and particle effects but found the overall detail close to Super Mario Sunshine.
  • The frame rate dips occasionally. Navarro praised the engine but noted drops in "infrequent bouts."
  • No voice acting. GameRevolution's Chris Hudak criticized its absence, then admitted voices would "probably seem lame and wrong."
  • Completion takes a long time. The 121st star means collecting all 120 as Mario, then all 120 again as Luigi, who is the harder character to play.

If you're looking for a game to play with a partner, the critics' praise doesn't extend to that mode. If you're playing alone, the game delivers nearly everything critics promised.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet