Super Mario Maker 2 shines for builders and stumbles when you play online
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics agreed on the building and split on online play
Almost nobody argued about the editor. Metacritic rates Super Mario Maker 2 as "generally favorable," and OpenCritic shows 95% of critics recommending it, with a "mighty" rating. The aggregate scores sit close together: 88/100 from 119 reviews, 88/100 from 24 reviews of the Switch version and 89/100 from 12. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, comes out at 8.8.
The real disagreement was over playing with other people online. Up to four players can run user-made courses together or against each other, and critics faulted that mode for performance problems. GameSpot still gave the game an 8/10 but said online lag often ruined the experience. That split matters more than the score, because it shows which half of the game the praise is about.
Builders get the strongest version of the idea
Most of the praise is about making courses. A course can use the look and rules of Super Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros. 3, Super Mario World or New Super Mario Bros. U, and enemies and mechanics behave differently from one style to the next. The sequel adds a Super Mario 3D World theme, redone in 2.5D. It's labeled an "extra" style with features only it has, and switching a course to it means resetting the course, so it's a choice to make at the start.
- Vertical courses raise the height limit, so a level can climb instead of only running left to right.
- Two players can build a course together on one Switch.
- World Maker links courses into a Super World: up to eight worlds of up to five levels each, with Toad houses for extra-life minigames and Warp Pipes for shortcuts. You can save six Super Worlds but upload only one.
The World Maker map always uses the Super Mario World look, though the courses on it can use any style. If you've ever drawn your own Mario game on paper, this is the closest the series has come to letting you make one.
Story Mode gives non-builders a full game
Players who never plan to place a block still get a full game. In Story Mode, Mario, Toadette and a group of Toads rebuild Princess Peach's castle after Undodog accidentally resets it. You collect coins for the rebuild across more than 100 courses made by Nintendo, and other characters hand out extra jobs along the way. It's a single-player campaign, so it avoids the online play critics complained about.
Sharing depends on a subscription and on Nintendo's moderators
Everything online, even just browsing courses other players made, requires a Nintendo Switch Online subscription. Much of the appeal is the steady supply of other people's levels, so plan on paying for it.
Moderation is the other weak spot. Nintendo has drawn steady criticism for deleting levels with vague explanations, often over courses that rely on unintended mechanics or glitches. In June 2019, the speedrunner David Hunt, known as GrandPooBear, had a course removed as "harmful or inappropriate content" and said he had no idea why. In April 2026, Nintendo removed a large batch of levels at once, and IGN estimated the count in the thousands. The creator Alex Tan, known as PangaeaPanga, was told some of his levels were deleted for "advertising." He suspected the community hashtags that creators put in level descriptions, and the YouTuber DGR backed that theory.
If you build to share, assume Nintendo can take an upload down without a clear reason, and leave hashtags out of level names and descriptions.
What the split means for you
Read the record as two games. The builder's game (the editor, World Maker and Story Mode) earned near-unanimous praise. The online game, playing with or against strangers, is where reviewers found lag, and it's behind a subscription. If you mostly want to make courses, play Nintendo's own or build side by side with someone at home, the critics' praise applies to you in full. If online play is the main draw, expect less.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Super Mario Maker 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q61831178 wikidata.org