Super Mario Maker hands you Nintendo's toolbox, but the audience has gone
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A toolbox first, a Mario game second
Super Mario Maker is built on one idea: give players the parts Nintendo uses to make Mario levels, then let them build, play and share their own. Courses come in four styles, Super Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros. 3, Super Mario World and New Super Mario Bros. U, and all four run on the physics of New Super Mario Bros. U.
Critics bought the idea quickly. IGN's Jose Otero called it a "fun, flexible toolbox," and most reviews judged the game on two things: how well the toolbox works and what people built with it. The critic aggregate came to 89/100 across 88 reviews, and the critic average of 8.9 is based on it. A game built around a toolbox has three parts that have to hold up: the tools, the community and the sharing. Only two of them still do.
The editor earns the praise because the parts combine
Goombas, warp pipes and power-ups are all here. What makes the editor stand out is that its parts combine. Enemies stack on top of each other. Hazards can come out of question blocks and pipes. A shell can sit on Mario's head as a helmet, and a cannon can fire whatever object you choose. You can grow an enemy with a Super Mushroom or give it wings. Some elements cross between styles, so a Boo can show up in a Super Mario Bros. course. The Soundfrog adds sound and visual effects, though sounds recorded with the microphone are removed from uploaded courses.
GameSpot's Justin Haywald liked the "exciting and anachronistic" results of all that mixing. He also named the limits. Super Mario World's checkpoints don't carry over, and stages are capped in height and width. Otero found building intimidating at first but said the interface made it easy to learn. New parts become available over nine days of building. That spaces out the learning, but it also makes anyone who wants every tool on day one wait.
Players built harder courses than Nintendo would
A toolbox also has to be judged by what people make with it, and here the players went further than Nintendo did. In May 2016, Nintendo announced that players had made more than 7.2 million courses and played them more than 600 million times. Reviewers singled out individual creations. Mario co-creator Takashi Tezuka praised the library too. He noted that Nintendo holds back on difficulty in its own courses and players don't. He said watching inventive courses, like one you couldn't beat if you picked up a mushroom, pushed the developers to do better.
That missing restraint helped bring back the Kaizo community, whose courses are built to be extremely hard and test patience and skill.
A course could only be published after its creator had played it to completion. That one rule gave even the cruelest uploads a claim to being beatable.
The rollout had problems. Uploads were limited at first, and players had to earn stars from others to get medals that allowed more uploads. Many players criticized Nintendo for removing their courses without warning or explanation. Kotaku's Patrick Klepek argued that Nintendo should have made sure creators knew its rules about what levels it would allow.
The sharing half closed in April 2024
Sharing courses is no longer possible. Course World, where players browsed and played each other's courses, ran on the Wii U and 3DS online servers, and those servers shut down in April 2024. The 100 Mario Challenge, which strung together random player-made courses with 100 lives, depended on it.
The community gave it a good send-off. When the shutdown was announced, 25,000 courses had never been cleared. A group calling itself Team 0% set out to clear every one, and by March 2024 only 178 were left. "The Last Dance" was the final course cleared, on March 15. A course called "Trimming The Herbs" had been counted as the last until it came out that its creator had cleared it using TAS tools. Players beat it legitimately on April 5, three days before the shutdown.
The editor still works, and so does the 10 Mario Challenge, a set of pre-made courses with 10 lives. Polygon's Griffin McElroy said the game's biggest accomplishment was giving him a new appreciation for something he'd known his whole life. That came from building courses, and building doesn't need the servers.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Super Mario Maker en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17164955 wikidata.org