Analysis · Super Mario Odyssey

Super Mario Odyssey is easy to love and, for a few critics, hard to finish

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The argument was about originality, not quality

Critics rarely disagreed about whether Super Mario Odyssey was good. They disagreed about whether it was new. Metacritic logged "universal acclaim", and OpenCritic found that 98% of critics recommended it. Famitsu gave it 39/40, the same score it gave Super Mario 64. IGN and GameSpot both gave it a perfect 10 and singled out its originality.

Edge went further. Its staff praised the risks Nintendo took in breaking from the usual Mario formula and called the game the true spiritual successor to Super Mario 64, something the series hadn't managed before.

Phil Hornshaw of Digital Trends read the same game the other way. He gave it 4 out of 5 and wrote that it "lacks the innovation and creativity of Nintendo's best." That's the sharpest split in the reviews. One camp saw a bold reinvention. The other saw a very polished return to old ideas. Even the doubter thought it was fun.

Cappy is the strongest argument for the fans

The case for originality rests mostly on Cappy, a hat spirit that Mario throws at enemies, uses as a temporary platform or flings at objects to take them over. Capturing gives Mario borrowed abilities:

  • a Bullet Bill to fly across gaps
  • a Tyrannosaurus to trample objects
  • a Spark Pylon to ride along electric wires
  • a Sherm tank to shoot enemies and break blocks

Edge called capturing the most versatile ability the series had ever had. The game also drops Mario into flat 2D zones styled after the original Super Mario Bros. Andrew Webster of The Verge compared those sections to the puzzles in The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds, and VentureBeat noted similarities to the Sonic the Hedgehog series.

So the disagreement tells you something useful. If capturing a dinosaur sounds new and delightful, you'll probably side with Edge. If you mostly want sharper level design than past 3D Mario games, Hornshaw's milder reaction is the more likely result.

Worth playing, maybe not worth finishing

The second split is about how the game ends, or doesn't. Each of its 14 kingdoms asks for a minimum number of Power Moons before the ship, the Odyssey, can move on. Moons can come from anywhere, so most big objectives are optional. After Bowser falls, every kingdom refills with more moons. Two bonus levels open later: Dark Side, a boss rush that needs 250 moons, and Darker Side, a platforming gauntlet that needs 500.

One dissenting reviewer, a game designer, gave it a lukewarm write-up: absolutely worth playing, he argued, but not satisfying to finish.

That complaint lands hardest on completionists, the people most likely to chase that 500-moon gate. Webster saw the same loose structure as a strength. He wrote that it suits the Switch's portable design: you can follow the main missions in a long session or grab a few moons in a short one.

The stakes are low throughout. Lives are unlimited, and dying costs up to 10 coins. That makes the game friendly to younger players (it's rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7) and to anyone who plays in short sessions. Players who want a hard, tightly built finale may find the long tail thin.

Where the controls drew complaints

Two critics flagged precision problems. Webster found the motion controls "frustratingly imprecise" and preferred standard buttons. Some moves can be sped up with motion, but the game is fully playable with the controllers attached to the console, so motion controls are skippable. Hornshaw's complaint is harder to avoid: he called both the controls and the camera imprecise and frustrating.

Co-op is a lighter extra. A second player controls Cappy, who can move more freely than Mario, which suits a parent helping a child more than two experienced players.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet