Super Smash Bros. Brawl hides a deep fighter under one-button controls
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Simple to start, deep to master
GameSpot's Lark Anderson summed up the game's central idea: its "simple controls and gameplay make it remarkably accessible to beginners, yet still appealing to veterans". Nearly every other judgment of Brawl comes back to that claim, so each part of the game below is checked against it.
Edge took the same view. It noted that the series had often been "derided as button-mashing" but called Brawl "one of the most enduringly innovative and deep systems of any fighter". That is high praise for a game you play by pressing one button and tilting a stick.
A rising percentage replaces the health bar
Brawl has no health bar that runs down. Each fighter starts at 0%, and the number rises as they take damage, up to 999%. The higher it climbs, the farther a hit sends them flying. A fighter knocked past the edge of a stage loses a life, a point or coins, depending on the mode.
This rule is what makes the game easy to read and hard to master. A newcomer understands that knocking someone off the screen wins. A practiced player learns when a fighter's percentage is high enough for a finishing blow. The rest of the moveset is built the same way:
- Basic attacks come from a button plus a tilt of the stick or a press of the D-pad.
- Smash attacks are stronger versions of the same inputs.
- Each character has four unique special moves, which often do more than deal damage.
- New Final Smashes are powerful super attacks, triggered by breaking a floating Smash Ball.
Game Informer praised the "finely tuned balance" and core mechanics. Famitsu, which gave the game a perfect score, liked how unpredictable Final Smashes are. That unpredictability, along with items, Assist Trophies and Poké Balls that summon uncontrollable helpers, gives casual players a chance against stronger ones. Players who want a clean contest will see it as noise.
Where the idea falls short
The accessible-but-deep design holds up in the fighting. It holds up less well in the modes around it.
IGN's Matt Casamassina called Brawl "completely engrossing and wholly entertaining", but he criticized the Subspace Emissary adventure mode for "long loading times" and "uninspired enemies and locales". He described the graphics as "an enhanced version of Melee", with backgrounds that lack detail in places, and GameSpy compared the visuals to the GameCube.
Online play drew the clearest complaint. Mitchell Saltzman of Gameworld Network was disappointed by the lack of "stat tracking, voice chat, and a mostly lag free environment". A game built on precise timing suffers when the connection is unreliable, so the depth Edge praised mostly shows up when players are in the same room.
Familiar by design
Some critics thought the formula was getting old. NGamer's Matthew Castle wrote:
"Smash Bros risks growing too familiar. It never breeds contempt, but it doesn't quite muster that Galaxy magic."
Jeff Gerstmann gave it 4 out of 5 stars on Giant Bomb and warned that players who don't care about Nintendo's history or about multiplayer "probably won't understand what all the fuss is about". 1UP.com disagreed somewhat and called the game "a curious diversion for uninterested gamers". Even the skeptics agreed that the game is easy to get into. The doubts were about how much it changes from Melee, not about whether it plays well.
Built for a full room
Brawl's strongest case is local multiplayer. Eurogamer said it fulfilled its usual role of "dominating a willing crowd's evening into the early hours", and added that the single-player content keeps it going after everyone goes home. GameTrailers pointed to the amount of content as giving it "staying power that few other games possess". Game Revolution called the soundtrack "spectacular".
IGN's 2008 awards gave Brawl Best Fighting Game, Best Local Multiplayer Game and Best Original Score on Wii. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences named it Fighting Game of the Year. The critic average of 9.5 comes from a single critic score, and the wider reception supports it, with its known weaknesses in the side modes.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Super Smash Bros. Brawl en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q843131 wikidata.org