Analysis · Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate brings back every fighter and mostly earns it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The whole idea is that nobody gets left out

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate starts from a simple, expensive idea: bring back every fighter from every earlier game, add newcomers, and put the series' best ideas in one place. That adds up to 74 playable fighters, from Nintendo's own characters to ones borrowed from third-party franchises.

Critics treated that promise as the main event. IGN called the return of the full cast "ambitious and excellent." Jeuxvideo.com named it the best game in the series and praised how it mixes "gargantuan content with nostalgia." Across the reviews, the praise came back to the same three things: the huge cast, the long list of stages, and how well it pulls together what worked in earlier entries.

On OpenCritic, 97% of critics recommended it. Metacritic lists its reception as "universal acclaim."

A simple fighting system keeps a huge roster readable

A cast this big only works if the core rules stay easy to follow, and they do. Each player has a percentage meter that climbs as they take hits. The higher it goes, the farther attacks launch them, until one blow knocks them out of the arena. Up to eight players can fight at once.

You choose how a match is won:

  • Timed: most KOs before the clock runs out.
  • Stock: a set number of lives, and the last player standing wins.
  • Stamina: the percentage is replaced by hit points that run down to zero.

Items, Poké Balls, Assist Trophies and each fighter's Final Smash can all be switched on or off, and rule sets can be saved as presets. That control is what lets a room of casual players and a pair of serious rivals use the same game. Bleacher Report singled out the faster pace and the bright, colorful art style, both of which help a crowded screen stay legible.

The same idea applied to stages, modes and music

The everything-included approach goes well beyond fighters. The base game has 103 stages, plus one more added in a free update. Most stages have hazards you can turn off, and each one also has a Battlefield form and an Omega form with standard layouts. Stage Morph switches between two chosen stages during a match.

The new modes stick closely to the main idea. Smashdown lets each fighter be picked only once, so a group works through the roster as it plays. Squad Strike runs team battles of three or five fighters. Tourney sets up playoff brackets for up to 32 players. Classic, Special Smash and Home-Run Contest are also back.

The Verge praised the very large soundtrack and the portable music player, which lets the game's music play on its own. It's an odd extra, but it fits a game that wants to hold on to all of its history.

Where more stops meaning better

The idea falls apart in two places. The first is online play. Reviewers and players reported heavy lag, even on a wired connection. Matchmaking often put players into matches with rules they hadn't picked, made it hard for friends to join each other instead of strangers, and didn't let several local players go online together. There were so many complaints on the game's subreddit that its moderators moved them all into one separate thread. Lag and loading times are reported to be better on the Nintendo Switch 2, which can run Switch games such as this one.

The second is World of Light, the single-player campaign. Critics were split. Some found it easy to get into and still challenging. Others called it tedious and far longer than it needed to be. That split is the downside of the everything-included approach: a mode built to be huge feels like a reward to some players and like homework to others.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet