Analysis · Dead or Alive Xtreme Beach Volleyball

Team Ninja traded fists for a volleyball and a swimsuit closet

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A fighting series that stopped fighting

Team Ninja built Dead or Alive as a fighting series. This 2003 Xbox spin-off, published by Tecmo, drops the fighting completely. The women from the fighting games spend a two-week vacation on an island, and the only contest left is two-on-two beach volleyball.

It also earned the first Mature rating in the series' history, for partial nudity. That rating tells you as much about the change as the new genre does. Edge's review focused on the game's social structure rather than competition, and that's the right way to see it: the volleyball matters, but it serves a game about relationships and wardrobes.

Critics mostly liked it. It averaged 73/100 at Metacritic and 74% at GameRankings, though individual scores ran from poor to very high.

What changed: a calendar, a shop and a friendship meter

The main mode is a schedule. You pick one woman and play out her two weeks, choosing one activity each morning, afternoon and evening. Most slots go to recruiting new partners or challenging existing pairs to a match, though you can also just relax.

Winning pays money, which buys swimsuits and accessories for your character or as gifts for the others. A casino on the island gives you a second way to earn. The money, called "Zack bucks," carries over between vacations, so a later play-through with a different character starts with whatever you didn't spend.

The relationship system ties it together:

  • Gifts and good play raise the other women's opinion of your character.
  • A partner who likes you plays better on the court.
  • Strong ties with others open up new partners.
  • A partner who doesn't like you makes mistakes, and may throw your gifts away unopened.

Swimsuits stay with the character who earned them, and each character's shop stocks a different set, so most of any one woman's suits only come as gifts. The design pushes you toward replaying with every character and filling every closet. That's the real long game here, more than any tournament.

What it kept: Team Ninja's focus on timing

The volleyball is simpler and better than its reputation. You use two buttons, one to spike and block and one to receive and set. Jumping and positioning mostly happen on their own, so the skill is in timing: press too early or late and you get a weak hit or put the ball into the net. Your partner covers whatever part of the court you leave open, and you can also steer her toward or away from the net.

It's also one of the few games to use the pressure-sensitive face buttons on the Xbox controller. A light press can just tip the ball over the net, which gives a two-button game more nuance than it looks like it has.

Critics noticed. Reviewers praised the depth of the volleyball, and Maxim called the action "pretty solid" despite clearly being interested in something else. At the first Spike Video Game Awards in 2003, the game won Best Animation and was nominated for Best Sports Game.

The part critics couldn't look past

Many of the costumes are revealing enough that the women look almost nude, and the suggestive poses can be viewed and zoomed from almost any angle. Most of the coverage focused on that, for better or worse.

GamesRadar ranked the game's gravure scenes among the 100 greatest moments in gaming in 2006. GameSpot named it Most Embarrassing Game of 2003.

Between those two extremes, the warmer reviews still included caveats. Entertainment Weekly gave it a B and called it a "goofy title" that was hard not to get caught up in. Playboy scored it 74% and called it "mildly entertaining" as long as you knew what you were getting.

That's a fair way to judge it. The volleyball is solid, but it's a small part of a game built to show off its cast. The players it fits are the ones who enjoy the collecting and the vacation routine, not just tolerate them. Matches use Japanese voices throughout, while the CG cutscenes have both English and Japanese voiceovers.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet