Analysis · Temple of Yog

Temple of Yog bets everything on the Wii U GamePad, and critics split over it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The split is between the idea and the whole game

Critics agreed on what Temple of Yog does differently. They didn't agree on whether that was enough. The game landed at 54 on Metacritic, and an aggregate of seven reviews dated March 9, 2016 put it at 55 out of 100. Those are middling numbers, but the reviews behind them weren't all lukewarm.

At the top end, Mike Diver of Vice wrote that there was more to the game than first impressions suggest. He found it grew compelling quickly and guessed it could become a 2016 "cult hit". Tyler Treese of We Got This Covered was more guarded. He called it a "fun diversion" and said it was worth a look despite its problems. He also told Wii U owners they owed it to themselves to try one of the few games that really uses the GamePad.

Even the praise comes with conditions, then. The game's admirers liked its central trick and its slow-building pull. The middling scores suggest that plenty of critics didn't stick around long enough to feel that pull, or didn't think it made up for the rough edges.

Two screens, two worlds, one maze

Temple of Yog is a 2D retro-style shoot 'em up roguelike from independent developer ChudChud Industries. Its core idea is simple to describe. The TV shows the light side of the labyrinth and the GamePad shows the shadow side. Using shadow power, your character can teleport between the two.

Whichever world you're not in stays visible on the second screen. That lets you look ahead before jumping across: you can check the layout of the maze and spot enemies on the other side. This is the part critics singled out, and it's the reason the game stands out from other small action games of its era. Levels and the item system are procedurally generated from player data, so the maze changes from run to run.

Four guilds and a loop of short runs

A tutorial as 'Ao the Original' covers movement, defense and shooting, and it ends with the Compass item. After that, you pick a tribute from one of four guilds:

  • The Holy Augers (clerics), who can heal themselves
  • The Cult of the Magi (mages), who can raise a shield
  • The Livid Blades (warriors), with a high-powered fireball
  • The Rogue's Nest (rogues), with a fast roll

Each guild has its own HP, MP and shadow power, and each plays differently in range, strength and attack speed. Your tribute gets a generated name, such as Gougre the Worldly, before entering the temple.

Runs start at a portal at the top of the temple, where you can equip an item you've already earned. Inside, you fight spiders and snakes and take quests from colored obelisks to earn Boon Points. At the end of a run you're ranked anywhere from "pitiful" to "worthy", and you spend Boon on guild stat upgrades. It's a grind-and-improve loop, and it explains Diver's point that the game gets better the longer you stay with it.

Who the disagreement points to

The reviews sort players fairly cleanly. If you judge a game by its first half hour, the middling scores are probably right for you. If you like roguelikes that pay you back for repeated runs and stat upgrades, the warmer reviews describe the game you'll find.

The GamePad matters more than usual here. The game only came out on Wii U, in North America on December 16, 2015, and in Europe on January 7, 2016. Its best feature can't exist without that second screen. The festival circuit saw something in it too: it was an official selection in the Digital category at IndieCade 2015.

The hook is the second screen. If that idea doesn't interest you, critics gave little reason to think the rest of the game will.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet