Analysis · Terraria

Terraria kept changing for a decade, and critics liked it more each time

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The first game in the series is still the one people play

Terraria is where the series starts, and its long life defines the series. Re-Logic released it on May 16, 2011, and it has since come to 16 platforms, from Xbox 360 and PlayStation Vita to Nintendo Switch and PlayStation 5. Re-Logic didn't follow it with a new game. It kept working on this one.

That changed how critics rated it. PC Gamer doesn't normally re-review games, but it did for Terraria and raised its score from 79 to 83, because the game had become so different from what launched. GameStar reviewed it in 2020 and gave it 85 out of 100. The critic average, worked out from critic aggregates, is 8.2 out of 10.

What the updates added

Most of the changes give you more control over how hard the game is and how you play it:

  • Difficulty: on top of Classic, Expert and Master modes make the game harder and give out items you can't get anywhere else.
  • A creative-style mode: it lets you duplicate items, change the world's difficulty, and control the weather and time of day.
  • Teaching: the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 releases added a separate tutorial world, which critics liked. The PC version had no tutorial and was criticized for it.
  • Extras: fishing, golf, pets and clothing dyes. GameStar's Sascha Penzhorn mentioned the pets and dyes.

Penzhorn said the fourth major update made the game "more accessible and more challenging" than it had been before. Modding counts as another change. Re-Logic began officially supporting tModLoader in 2020, and IndieWire wrote that mods have "added hundreds of hours" of content. In 2024 the Opera GX browser ranked the Calamity mod's soundtrack ninth among the best game soundtracks ever. The base game's soundtrack didn't make the list.

What stayed the same, good and bad

The core hasn't changed. You still start in a procedurally generated 2D world, drawn in a style that looks like 16-bit Super Nintendo sprites, with basic tools, an NPC guide and no set goals. Critics liked the retro art from the start. At IGN, Nathan Meunier said the urge to explore kicks in right away. GameSpot's Britton Peele praised the size of the world, and Tom Mc Shea praised the boss fights.

The crafting has always split critics. Meunier and Mc Shea enjoyed how many options it gives you. Phill Cameron of Eurogamer didn't like how complicated it is, and Luke Winkie had the same complaint in PC Gamer's 2018 re-review, seven years after launch. Ben Reeves of Game Informer said the game doesn't explain its mechanics well and called it "tiring and frustrating". A study by scholar Ji Soo Lim found that its participants had to look things up on a wiki to make progress.

The game doesn't tell you most of what you need to know. Plan to keep a wiki open.

It has more structure than the Minecraft comparison suggests

Critics kept comparing it to Minecraft, but the more careful ones pointed out what's different. Peele called the comparison "somewhat unfair". Eurogamer's Christian Donlan saw it as a mix of Minecraft and Spelunky. Polygon's Philip Kollar said Terraria "has more structure, more goals", and Matt Kamen of The Guardian said it puts more weight on combat.

Boss fights are what give it that structure. Beating the Wall of Flesh moves the world into hardmode, which brings tougher enemies, new NPCs and new resources. Invasions by goblins, pirates or aliens, along with seasonal events, interrupt your building, and NPCs like a merchant or a nurse move into houses you build once you reach certain goals. Meunier praised that village building, and Winkie liked the progression system.

Which version to pick

  • PlayStation Vita: the one critics liked most. Meunier praised its tutorial and interface, and Mc Shea praised its movement controls.
  • Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3: critics liked the controls and Peele liked the system for inviting friends to multiplayer, but Meunier criticized the interface.
  • Nintendo Switch: Mitch Vogel of Nintendo Life criticized the controls.
  • iOS: Mark Brown of Pocket Gamer liked the mining but not the movement.
  • 3DS and Wii U: Marcel van Duyn of Nintendo Life liked the 3DS touchscreen controls, but that version launched without online multiplayer. He said the Wii U version's multiplayer was better.

Multiplayer is worth doing on any version. Meunier and Kollar both enjoyed it, and co-op lets friends split up the digging and the boss fights.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet