The 2011 game that teaches by killing you returns, cleaner but unchanged
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every death is a lesson, and the game is built on that
Critics kept coming back to one idea: Dark Souls teaches through failure. GameSpot wrote about the joy of finally beating a boss after many failed attempts. Another early reviewer said the happiness you get when trial and error finally pays off is "absolutely impossible to replicate." The rest of the design supports that loop. You learn where enemies stand, how they attack and which route is safer, mostly by dying to them first.
The remaster doesn't touch that design. FromSoftware made the 2011 original. QLOC developed this 2018 version, which Bandai Namco Entertainment published on Windows, PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch, and critics treated it as a cleaner way to play the same game.
Lordran is a map you learn by heart
The kingdom of Lordran is one connected world. Its regions loop back on each other through shortcuts you open as you go, and many areas can be reached by more than one route. Some paths stay closed until you meet certain conditions, so knowing the map is part of making progress.
Bonfires are the checkpoints. Resting at one restores your health and Estus Flask charges, and it's where you level up, attune magic and repair or upgrade gear. Resting also brings back most enemies, though not bosses. Each stretch between bonfires becomes a rehearsal you repeat until you know it.
That's where the praise was strongest. IGN and Eurogamer both singled out the level design and atmosphere. Edge went further and retroactively gave the game 10 out of 10 in its October 2013 anniversary issue, saying the breadth and quality of the design outweighed complaints about the difficulty.
Dying costs you something real
Defeating enemies earns souls, which are both your money and your experience points. When you die, you drop every soul you're carrying where you fell. Reach that bloodstain and you get them back. Die again on the way and they're gone for good. Magic follows the same strict logic: spells have a set number of uses that only refill at a bonfire, not a mana pool that recharges.
Those stakes are why the lessons stick. They're also where critics drew a line:
"There's a difference between punishing, and downright unfair." (IGN)
- GameSpot and Eurogamer both suggested casual players may struggle to make progress.
- Game Informer's Phil Kollar praised the steep difficulty but was less kind about the game's "overall lack of direction."
The game rewards patience and gives little guidance, so you have to want to learn it the hard way.
Other players' deaths become your guide
The online features fit the same idea. You see ghostly images of other players, leave messages built from preset phrases, and touch bloodstains to watch how someone else died. Other people's failures become warnings you can use. GameSpot praised this online system.
Restoring human form by spending humanity at a bonfire lets you summon other players for help, but it also opens you to invasions from hostile players. Optional factions called covenants push you toward cooperation or toward invading others. You can finish the game without any of it.
This is the remaster's weak spot. Critics criticized the lack of an effective anti-cheat system. On Windows, online services were shut off in January 2022 after a security exploit was found, and Remastered's online features there came back in November 2022.
What the remaster adds, and what it doesn't
Critics praised the improved visuals and performance. That matters more on PC than it might sound. GameSpy called the original Windows port "shabby" for its 30 frames per second limit, poor mouse and keyboard controls and fixed resolution.
The main complaint was about value: the PC version's price despite few significant changes. Critic scores still landed between 83 and 87 out of 100 across the four platforms. In Japan it sold 71,739 copies in its launch week, making it the country's best-selling game at the time.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Dark Souls: Remastered en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q55728812 wikidata.org