Analysis · Age of Empires: Definitive Edition

The Age of Empires remake sells an empire and plays like a war

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

An empire builder that critics read as a war game

Age of Empires is built on one promise: take a handful of hunter-gatherers and grow them into an expansive Iron Age empire. You advance through four ages (Stone, Tool, Bronze and Iron), and each step opens new technologies, weapons and units.

Critics in 1997 liked the game but didn't fully believe the promise. GameSpot called it "Warcraft with a hint of Civilization" and said it was "a simple combat game rather than a glorious empire-builder." Game Informer described it as a cross between Warcraft and SimCity. Game Revolution put it between Civilization II and Warcraft II.

That gap between the pitch and the play explains the rest of the game. It's a real-time strategy game where the economy exists to feed the army.

Finite resources turn every age into a race

The economy is the part that best delivers on the empire idea. You gather resources to pay for units, buildings and research, and those resources don't come back. A tree you cut down stays cut down. Each move to a new age is researched at the Town Center, so the whole match is a question of when to spend on growth and when to spend on soldiers.

Because resources run out, the empire never settles into a comfortable peace. That pressure is why critics saw a combat game. The map pushes you toward conflict over what's left.

  • Four single-player campaigns follow the Egyptians, Greeks, Babylonians and Yamato through linear scenarios.
  • Random map generates a new map each game, and GameVortex said it "really keeps the game spiced up."
  • Death match is a resource-heavy variant for players who want to skip the slow start.

Micromanagement is the price of the fighting

If the game is mostly about war, the controls should make war easy to run. Critics said they didn't. GameSpot called the amount of micromanagement "a poor idea" that "seriously diminishes" the fun, blaming the lack of production queues and weak AI for your own units. GameVortex agreed.

Computer Gaming World's Elliott Chin picked the population limit as the game's "most serious grievance," even while calling it the most sophisticated real-time strategy game of its day. PC Gameworld noted that patches after release fixed some of the faulty AI.

The empire you're promised is capped by how many units you can field and how many you can steer by hand.

GameVortex also faulted the sound, saying the audio cues weren't enough to tell what was happening on the field.

Twelve civilizations and an editor give the idea depth

Where the game does feel like history, critics noticed. There are 12 civilizations, from the Assyrians and Minoans to the Shang and Yamato, sorted into four architectural styles. Each has its own technologies, so no single civilization can research everything. PC Gameworld praised how distinct each one is, and Game Revolution said the developers "obviously did [their] research."

The Scenario Builder lets players make their own scenarios and campaigns. Game Revolution singled it out as a tool for building a scenario "exactly to your liking." It's simpler than later editors and can do less, but it's easy to learn.

A remake that scored below its source

The original earned an 83 out of 100 on Metacritic and won Gamecenter's 1997 Game of the Year. The Definitive Edition, released for Microsoft Windows on February 20, 2018 by developer Forgotten Empires and publisher Xbox Game Studios, landed lower: 70/100 across 46 critic reviews, 67/100 across five Windows reviews, and a 7/10 from one outlet. That works out to a critic average of 6.9.

That drop fits the central tension. A 1997 design that critics already called more war than empire, with heavy micromanagement and a tight population cap, had more competition in 2018, including later games in its own series.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet