The city is the star, and cover finally makes the gunfights work
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A benchmark with one loud dissent
Critics rarely agree this strongly. Metacritic lists Grand Theft Auto IV as the second-highest-rated game on the site and the top-rated game on both PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360. IGN's Hilary Goldstein said it "sets a new benchmark for open-world games".
The sharpest pushback came from GameRevolution's Jesse Costantino. He felt the game lacked important features common in other open world games, and he described the online mode as "broken" because of connectivity problems.
The two views don't actually clash. The praise covers what the game does: its city, its lead character and its combat. The criticism covers what it leaves out or doesn't deliver reliably. If you mainly want a story-driven crime game in a convincing city, the praise is the part that matters to you.
Liberty City is the reason critics kept coming back
Liberty City is based on New York City. It spans four boroughs across three islands, plus the neighbouring state of Alderney, which is based on New Jersey. The map is larger than most earlier entries in the series. You start with only Bohan, Broker and Dukes, and the other islands open up as the story moves forward.
Critics lined up behind the setting. Seth Schiesel of The New York Times called the city the "real star". Andy Robinson of Computer and Video Games found it believable and "utterly unmatched", and Crispin Boyer of 1UP.com praised its "breathtaking vistas" and lived-in look. Official Xbox Magazine's Jon Hicks credited the game's artificial intelligence for how alive the city feels. Goldstein added that it isn't a copy of New York, since it "exists in its own universe".
Sound is a big part of that. Reviewers at IGN, GameSpot and GamesRadar praised the licensed music, and GamesRadar's George Walter enjoyed the humour of the talk radio stations. Michael Pinson of The Pro Audio Files singled out how the city ambiance, music, dialogue and vehicle and weapon effects work together. Between missions there's bowling, darts, a vigilante mini-game and in-game television.
Niko Bellic gives a darker story its weight
You play Niko Bellic, an Eastern European war veteran trying to escape his past while high-profile criminals lean on him. Goldstein noted that the darker tone breaks from series tradition, and critics broadly treated that as a strength.
Niko got some of the warmest praise on record. Hicks and Robinson both called him "charismatic" and "likeable" and preferred him to earlier series leads. Giant Bomb's Jeff Gerstmann said Niko became "the only thing that mattered" to him as the story went on.
The story also asks you to make morality choices that change how it plays out. Boyer said they add "replayability", and Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell saw them as a fair replacement for "bosses with large health bars". Friendships matter as well: spend time with friends and their respect grows, which earns favours. For example, Niko's cousin Roman will send one of his cabs for a free ride.
Cover finally makes the gunfights work
Combat is where critics saw the biggest jump over earlier games. The cover system lets you move between obstacles, fire blindly, aim freely and target specific body parts, with auto-aim available as backup. GameSpot's Justin Calvert called the result a "huge improvement", and Empire's David McComb described the combat as "sharp and instinctive".
Most reviewers also found the driving more realistic than before. Even Costantino, the game's toughest critic, praised the physics engine's vehicle and character animations. Police chases follow a wanted meter that tops out at six stars, and escaping means getting outside the search area and staying out of sight.
Online play split the critics
You reach multiplayer through Niko's cell phone. Most critics liked it: Game Informer's Andrew Reiner said it runs "just as smoothly" as the single-player game, Hicks found it "hugely entertaining" and Boyer called it "excellent". Gerstmann and Costantino were more divided, with Costantino calling it a "fantastic idea" let down by connection problems.
That split tells you how to approach it. Buy the game for the single-player story, and count the online mode as a bonus if it works for you.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Grand Theft Auto IV en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q94797 wikidata.org