The Doom Slayer slows down to a shield-first brawl, and critics split on it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics agreed it's good and argued over whether it's new
Almost no critic called Doom: The Dark Ages a weak game. They argued about how new it is. GameSpot said it takes the series in a "bold new direction" without leaving its roots behind. IGN's Mitchell Saltzman wrote that its heavy, powerful style is unlike anything the series had done before.
The other camp read the same game as a step back. PC Gamer's Morgan Park found it "surprisingly safe." TheGamer's Jade King called it the weakest entry in the modern trilogy and wanted something that rethought what playing Doom means. Vulture said it "feels recursive" because it stays too close to the games before it.
Both camps describe the same design. id Software slowed the Doom Slayer down and handed him a shield instead of more speed. How that change lands depends mostly on what you loved about Doom Eternal.
The Slayer is built like a tank now
Doom (2016) and Doom Eternal were built on fast, acrobatic movement. This prequel asks you to stand your ground. The game calls the Doom Slayer an "iron tank," and the toolset matches that:
- The Shield Saw blocks, parries and attacks with a single input.
- Melee weapons include a gauntlet, an iron mace and a flail.
- The new Skull Crusher fires bone fragments.
- Glory kills now play in slow motion, which gives you more control in a fight.
- For the first time in the series, you pilot vehicles in certain sections: a cybernetic dragon and a 30-story Atlan mech.
The story gets more room too. There are more cutscenes and more character work, and they explore the Slayer's origins during a demonic invasion of the planet Argent D'Nur. Multiplayer is gone. This is a single-player game only.
Who the slower pace will win over
The praise came from critics who enjoy combat as a set of decisions more than a test of reflexes. Game Informer's Marcus Stewart called it "modern Doom executed better than ever" and a strategic ride that kept testing him. IGN admitted the game drops Eternal's focus on mobility and still found the heavier style deeply satisfying in its own way.
A simple test: if dashing and juggling were the whole point of Doom Eternal for you, expect a different game. If you liked the fights more than the movement, this is likely your Doom.
Players who want a bit more story will also get more here than in recent entries. The same goes for anyone curious about riding a dragon or piloting a mech between the ground fights.
Who it may leave cold
If you want each Doom to rebuild itself from the ground up, the critics on the skeptical side are speaking to you. TheGamer and Vulture both counted the new combat and exploration ideas and still found the game too careful. The Washington Post liked the shield-based combat but missed the series' signature "glory kills" and found the music less impactful. Players who came to Doom for multiplayer will find none.
The numbers lean clearly favorable
Metacritic rates it "generally favorable" at 86/100 on Windows, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S, each from 59 reviews. OpenCritic found that 95% of critics recommended it. The critic average of 8.6 comes from those critic aggregates and isn't a separate grade.
Players showed up too. The game reached 3 million players in its first week, seven times faster than Doom Eternal and the biggest launch in id Software's history. It was also the first Doom on Xbox Game Pass at launch, so that comparison isn't quite like for like.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Doom: The Dark Ages en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q126091569 wikidata.org