The highest-rated game of 2006 returns on Wii U with its rough edges intact
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The loudest praise and the sharpest knocks came in the same year
Few games have arrived with praise this loud. When Twilight Princess first came out in 2006, Cubed3 called it "the single greatest videogame experience" and GameTrailers named it one of the greatest games ever created. Writers at IGN, Game Informer, 1UP.com and The Washington Post called it the best Zelda yet. It was the highest-rated game of 2006 on Metacritic, with 95/100 on Wii and 96/100 on GameCube.
The criticism was narrower but pointed. IGN and GameSpy both flagged blurry textures and low-resolution characters, the cost of a game built for the GameCube. GameSpot's Jeff Gerstmann called the Wii motion controls "tacked-on", and IGN said the MIDI soundtrack lacked "the punch and crispness" of orchestrated music.
Twilight Princess HD is that same adventure on Wii U, developed by Tantalus Media and Nintendo Entertainment Planning & Development and released on March 4, 2016 in North America and Europe. The praise is real and well documented. So are the limits.
Link spends much of the game as a wolf
At its core, this is classic 3D Zelda. Link fights with a sword and shield, backs them up with a bow, a boomerang and bombs, and locks onto enemies with the targeting system the series introduced in Ocarina of Time. One context-sensitive button handles talking, opening doors, and pushing, pulling or throwing objects, and the screen shows what it will do before you press it.
The twist is the Twilight, a void that has corrupted parts of Hyrule. Inside it, Link turns into a wolf, and later he can switch forms at will. As a wolf he loses his sword, shield and items, so he attacks by biting and survives by dodging. In return he runs faster, digs new passages, uncovers buried items and follows scent trails. His wolf senses also let him see and hear the spirits of people caught in the Twilight, and hunt ghosts called Poes.
Riding on his back is Midna, a small imp-like companion who gives hints, attacks with an energy field, helps with long jumps and eventually lets Link warp between set points. That warp matters. The nine dungeons are spread across a large overworld that Link crosses on foot, on his horse Epona, or by teleporting.
Each dungeon is a contained space full of enemies, items and puzzles, and each ends with a boss who guards a new item or the next step in the story. Computer and Video Games rated this Hyrule the best version of the kingdom ever made, with a stronger atmosphere than any earlier Zelda.
Art direction won awards while the hardware drew complaints
The art style and animation drew steady praise and a lot of trophies. IGN and Nintendo Power both gave it Best Graphics and Best Story, and IGN gave the GameCube version Best Artistic Design, Best Original Score and Best Use of Sound. PALGN said its cutscenes were "the best ever" in the series.
The technical complaints were about the hardware underneath. Critics pointed out that the game was designed for the GameCube, which lagged behind the newer consoles of its day, and the blurry textures and rough character models showed it. The music split critics as well. Gaming Nexus called it the best soundtrack of its generation, while IGN wanted the fuller sound of a live orchestra.
Controls drew the clearest split. Gerstmann found the motion controls bolted on, but 1UP.com called the remote-swinging sword attacks the most impressive in the series. Both critics were judging the Wii Remote and Nunchuk, so their verdicts apply to that 2006 release rather than to this one.
The remaster scored well, just not as high
Twilight Princess HD holds 86/100 on Metacritic, a "generally favorable" rating. Critic aggregates from July 28, 2016 put it at 91% and 85/100 across 67 reviews, and the critic average computed from those aggregates is 8.5 out of 10.
That's a strong result, and it's still about 10 points below the original's Metacritic marks. Critics kept rewarding it anyway: it won Nintendo Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards in November 2016. It sold 52,282 copies in its first week in Japan, enough for second place on the chart, and had sold 1.17 million copies worldwide as of December 2022.
The record doesn't say why the remaster scored lower. The most likely reason is the plain one. It's a 2006 design, and in 2016 critics compared it with a decade of newer adventures. Its strengths are the same ones critics praised in 2006.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q23008476 wikidata.org