Analysis · The Last of Us Part II

The Last of Us Part II makes you play the person you set out to kill

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A revenge story told from both ends

Critics described a game built on one idea: follow a revenge story from both sides. Ellie sets out to avenge Joel's murder. Abby, the soldier who killed him, gets her own long stretch of the game, caught in a war between her militia and a religious cult. Control switches between the two, so you spend hours as the person Ellie is hunting.

Most critics thought the idea worked. IGN's Jonathon Dornbush called it "a masterpiece worthy of its predecessor." Game Informer's Andy McNamara called it "a sequel unlike any other." The Guardian's Keza MacDonald found the narrative "emotionally effective," and Push Square's Sammy Barker singled out the way its flashbacks and overlapping stories fit together.

The numbers back that up. Metacritic lists "universal acclaim," 94% of critics on OpenCritic recommend it, and the critic average, worked out from 45 critic scores, is 9.6 out of 10.

Stealth and crafting that keep every fight close

The play supports the idea by making violence slow and personal. You sneak through ruined buildings and forests, use Listen Mode to see enemies through walls, crawl through grass and craft what you need at the moment you need it:

  • health kits, Molotov cocktails and makeshift silencers from scavenged parts;
  • bricks and bottles thrown to distract or hit enemies;
  • weapon upgrades at workbenches, and a skill tree that grows as you find training manuals.

Enemies fight back with some intelligence. They take cover, call for help and push in when you're reloading. Guard dogs follow your scent. An arrow wound keeps draining your health and shuts off Listen Mode until you pull it out in cover. Dornbush credited the sequel with improved gameplay over the first game.

This is also where critics found the idea wobbling. USgamer's Kat Bailey criticized the gap between the game's message against violence and how much violence it requires. GameSpot's Kallie Plagge felt Abby's growth sat awkwardly beside her "onslaught of combat against human enemies," and The Verge's Andrew Webster saw a similar mismatch between how Ellie behaves in play and in cutscenes.

The characters carry the weight

If the two-sided structure works, it's because of the people in it. VG247's Kirk McKeand called every character "complex and human," and Dornbush found Ellie's arc "riveting." Webster praised the relationship between Ellie and Dina. Plagge wrote that she ended up more connected to Abby than to Ellie, which is the reaction the structure seems designed to provoke.

Critics also praised the cast's range. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh called it "a game about women," and The Spinoff's Sam Brooks called it a masterclass in inclusivity. NPR's Kaity Kline wrote about connecting with every character, not just the leads.

Not everyone agreed. Jeuxvideo.com's Yannick Le Fur felt supporting characters such as Jesse and Manny were there mainly to move the plot along. Polygon's Maddy Myers and Vice's Rob Zacny both criticized characters who never seem to learn from their mistakes.

Telling it twice makes it long

Following both sides of the story is also the source of most complaints. GameRevolution's Michael Leri saw the flashbacks as a sign of pacing problems. GamesRadar+'s Alex Avard felt the story lost momentum while it tied off every thread. Bailey found the second half slow and the game five hours "too long."

Others said the problem was repetition, not length. Myers and Kotaku's Riley MacLeod wrote that the game makes the same point again and again without letting you make any choices. Zacny argued that for all its big story moments, "it doesn't have much to say." Vice's Emanuel Maiberg saw parallels between its two warring factions and the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, and argued that framing them as equal sides was poorly thought through.

Your patience with Abby's half decides how you'll feel about the whole game. The critics who loved it said that half is the point.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet