The Music Quiz turns four plastic buzzers into a living room game show
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The buzzer is the whole idea
Critics kept coming back to one thing: this quiz comes with its own hardware. Every copy includes four buzzer controllers that plug into the PlayStation 2's USB slots. Each one has a large red button on top and four colored answer buttons below it. The red button is there so players can slap it the way contestants do on television, and the rest of the game is built around that feeling.
CNET's Randolph Ramsay called the buzzers a "welcome novelty". Eurogamer's Kristan Reed found them comfortable and easy to use with one hand, though a little flimsy. That trade-off makes sense for a party game. Anyone who picks one up knows what to do, which matters more than build quality when a grandparent and a teenager are playing in the same round.
Reed's verdict for Eurogamer: the "best quiz game ever released by a mile".
Eight round types keep the buzzer interesting
A game that only asked questions would wear thin quickly. The Music Quiz avoids that by changing the rules from round to round, and most of the changes alter how and when you use the buzzer:
- Fastest Finger gives the most points to the first correct answer, so speed beats certainty.
- Pass The Bomb makes you answer correctly to hand a ticking bomb to someone else. Whoever holds it when it goes off loses points.
- Point Stealer lets a correct answer take points from an opponent you choose.
- Offloader pays bonus points for guessing which of your rivals got the question right.
- Look Before You Leap reveals the question and answers bit by bit, so buzzing early is a gamble.
Outside the main game there are two more modes. Quickfire Quiz drops the rounds and becomes a straight race to a target score. Quizmaster Quiz puts one player in charge: that player picks the questions, the buzzers show who was fastest, and the quizmaster hands out points with a standard controller. You can set a main game to 15, 30 or 45 minutes and choose older music, newer music or both. The question pool runs to about 5,000 questions covering 50 years of pop.
The cheesy set is part of the joke
The game sends players to a fictional TV studio hosted by Buzz and his assistant Rose. Players choose from 16 contestant avatars modeled loosely on musicians such as Elvis Presley, Kylie Minogue and Barry White. The intro changes depending on who picked whom, with each contestant arriving by limousine to a cheering crowd.
Most critics thought the presentation suited the buzzer idea. Reed said it copies every game show cliché in an over-the-top, self-mocking way, and that even the "irritating host" works in that context. Ramsay found the characters "well defined and colorful". The praise wasn't unanimous, though. Gry Online's Krzysztof Gonciarz thought the character designs were nothing special. 4Players' Paul Kautz liked the animation but wanted more energy from the sound and the host.
Where the music quiz falls short is the music
The biggest complaint is a serious one for a game with music in its name. None of the roughly 1,000 clips are original recordings. They're synthesized versions of the songs with no vocals or lyrics. Trouw's John Hoogerwaard called them a "simple imitation". Reed said that because the clips didn't come from the artists, he often couldn't recognize them at first. Ramsay compared them to low-quality muzak.
That matters because the clips are your cue for a share of the questions. A song you'd name in two notes can take several seconds to place when it's a tinny synth melody, and in a game built around who buzzes first, those seconds count. Many questions ask about performers, titles, release years and artist trivia, so the quiz still works. It just works better as a pop-trivia game than as a test of your ear.
One limit to know before you look for a copy: the game came out only in Europe and Australia, on the PlayStation 2, on October 21, 2005.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Buzz!: The Music Quiz en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1169216 wikidata.org