Analysis · Star Wars: The Old Republic

The Old Republic puts a voiced BioWare story game inside an MMO

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea is a story game that happens to be online

Most online role-playing games treat story as a reason to go kill something. Critics described The Old Republic as working the other way round. Every character, including yours, is fully voiced. Conversations use a dialogue wheel like the one in the Mass Effect series, and each class gets its own story arc. Your choices permanently open or close storylines.

The setup adds a twist on the usual good and evil. You join the Galactic Republic or the Sith Empire, but your faction doesn't decide your morality. A Sith Empire character can follow the light side while chasing goals the Sith wouldn't share. That split between who you serve and who you are is the core of the design.

Critics responded to it. G4TV gave the game 5/5 and pointed to "top notch music and voice acting" and "hundreds of hours of content". PC Gamer scored it 93/100 for its story, voice acting and size. IGN called it "Amazing" at 9.0/10.

Companions are where your choices land

The story idea pays off most clearly through companion characters. You pick from a cast of non-player companions, and the game rewards sticking with one: time with a single companion develops more story than splitting it across several, and it can turn into a romance. Disappoint a companion and you can, in the developers' words, "blow it big time".

Companions also do mechanical work. Each class leans toward one role, such as ranged or melee damage, healing or tanking, but a companion fills the gaps. That means you can handle most situations alone, without needing a specific class in your group to move forward. GameSpy praised the companion system by name.

The system also showed how much players care about these choices. Vette, a slave companion for the Sith Warrior, became the center of a controversy after the Daily Mail claimed players weren't encouraged to treat her decently. That story drew criticism for thin evidence, and Religion Dispatches answered it with a survey of 369 players about how they roleplayed their choices with her.

Between the story beats sits a familiar MMO

Away from the cutscenes, the story idea fades. Leveling comes from missions, exploration and fights, and critics found much of it routine. GameSpy praised the storylines but faulted the "standard kill and fetch" quests. The most common complaint at launch was repetitive endgame content, which is where an online game has to hold you once the story runs out.

Space combat follows the same cinematic thinking as the story, with mixed results. Every player gets a starship, but space fights are a rail shooter: you move up, down, left and right on a fixed track, with no control of speed. The developers framed it as a way to make you feel "in the movies". It's a set piece rather than a flight game.

"[The Old Republic] isn't the next step in online role-playing games. Instead, it's a highly entertaining refinement of what has come before it." (GameSpot, 8.0/10)

That line is the fairest summary of the critical reaction. 1Up.com, giving it a B, called it "far from perfect" but said no game since World of Warcraft had offered something similar with such wide appeal.

A rough launch, and one critic who changed their mind

Launch week brought long queues on some servers. BioWare raised population caps and added servers to deal with them, and some pre-order players found their registration codes didn't work. Eurogamer later dropped its rating to 4/10 from an initial high score, the sharpest sign that some critics found the game wore thin after launch.

The awards leaned the other way. MSNBC named it game of the year, and the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences gave it Outstanding Achievement in Online Gameplay. The AbleGamers Foundation picked it as its Mainstream Game for 2011, citing full subtitles, queueable actions, multiple action bars and auto looting. For players who need those options, that is a real reason to pick it over other online games.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet