Analysis · Paper Mario: The Origami King

The Origami King swaps leveling for ring puzzles, and critics split

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The sixth Paper Mario keeps moving away from its role-playing roots

Intelligent Systems released The Origami King on Nintendo Switch on July 17, 2020. It's the sixth game in the Paper Mario series and follows Paper Mario: Color Splash (2016). It's billed as a role-playing game, but the design puts action-adventure and puzzles first.

Critics noticed the shift. They called the game new and unusual, but many felt it didn't reach the series' high points, and The Thousand-Year Door was the comparison they reached for most. The critic average, worked out from critic aggregates, is 7.8 out of 10, and 63% of critics recommended the game. That's a good result for a game that left part of its audience wanting something else.

What changed: battles on a dartboard

Combat is the big change. Fights are still turn-based, but Mario now stands in the center of a circular arena with four rings and 12 slots. You get a time limit and a set number of moves to slide the rings and line enemies up. Then you hit them with a hammer, which covers a two-by-two block next to Mario, or with boots, which cover a straight line of four. Line up every enemy and your attack gets stronger.

Boss fights flip the layout. The boss sits in the middle and Mario walks around the outside, following arrows across attack tiles and magic circle tiles. Each boss has its own rules. The Earth Vellumental, for example, has five exposed body parts you have to knock back before you can do real damage.

GameSpot called the system clever and said it turned the series' "Achilles' heel" into one of its strengths. Reviewers at Famitsu liked it as a puzzle. Critics generally rated the bosses as the best part.

What it cut, and why that hurt

The main complaint is what's missing. The game has no experience point system, and winning a normal fight earns only coins. Coins buy items and can pay rescued Toads to help in battle, but critics felt they didn't add up to much.

  • Cam Shea at IGN liked the idea but said the fights lacked meaning and felt like an inconvenience rather than a challenge.
  • Chris Kohler at Kotaku said coins sometimes made a battle worth it, but didn't come close to what experience points would offer.
  • Sean Morisson at ESPN missed the "satisfying progression" of leveling up, but wasn't sure how much it mattered given everything else the game does well.

That leaves a real split. The same system that makes boss fights memorable makes the many small fights feel optional at best and like busywork at worst. Some critics found them frustrating, and others found them too easy.

What it kept: jokes, paper and hidden things everywhere

The series' sense of humor is intact. Critics praised the dialogue across the cast. Olivia stood out for her personality, and Bobby drew attention for his role in the story. Electronic Gaming Monthly said the folded and crumpled Toads have funny lines that keep the hunt for them from going stale.

The world is the other strong point. Mario explores a linear open world made of paper and cardboard, following five streamers King Olly has wrapped around Princess Peach's castle. Critics compared the layout to The Legend of Zelda and said there's something to interact with almost everywhere. That includes collectible treasures for a museum, holes to fill with confetti, and spots where the 1000-Fold Arms let Mario peel back the scenery to find secrets. Reviewers also liked the soundtrack, which they called calm and catchy and which shifts as each area goes on.

The one real complaint about the art: GameSpot's Suriel Vazquez found the character designs less charming than in the early games.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet