The Settlers DS shrinks a 1996 strategy classic and breaks it on the way
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A well-loved sequel, carried over almost untouched
The Settlers DS isn't a new game. It's a 2007 port of The Settlers II Gold Edition, the 1997 package that bundled Blue Byte's 1996 original with its Mission CD expansion. The Settlers II was the second game in The Settlers series, after The Settlers (1993), and on PC it did very well with critics: an 84% aggregate on GameRankings, a 91% and Game of the Month from PC Games, and 89% from PC Gamer.
Ubisoft published the DS version. It came out in Germany on July 12, 2007, in Europe on August 3 and in North America on August 21. The changes were deliberately small. The screens were laid out for the DS's two displays and the controls were rebuilt around the stylus, but the gameplay, mechanics, graphics and story stayed exactly as they were.
What it kept: an economy that runs itself
The core is a city builder with real-time strategy on top. Each map starts with a single headquarters stocked with materials and tools. You never command an individual settler. You place buildings and roads, and serfs walk out of the warehouse on their own to haul goods and staff each workplace. When the warehouse runs out of settlers, you build another one. Military strength grows out of the economy, and you use it to take rival territory until you control the map or the target area.
The Gold Edition's content made the trip intact:
- a ten-mission campaign played as the Romans, plus nine more Roman missions from the Mission CD;
- a Free Game mode with Romans, Nubians, Vikings and Japanese, two to four races per map, and adjustable starting resources and victory conditions.
PC critics praised this economic design above everything else. Computer Gaming World's Tim Carter liked that wins and losses come from economics, not battlefield tactics. The weak spot was combat. GameSpot's Trent Ward called it "snore-inducing," and PC Player's Jörg Langer didn't like how little direct control you get over fights. None of that changed on the DS, for better or worse.
What it changed: a stylus that doesn't listen
The DS version's only real job was translating mouse controls to a touchscreen, and that's where critics saw it fail first. GameSpot, IGN, Pocket Gamer and Eurogamer all called the touchscreen unresponsive. GameSpot found map and menu scrolling "sluggish," while Pocket Gamer and Eurogamer called it jerky. Both of those outlets also said the menu icons were too small to tap reliably. That matters in a game where most of your time goes to placing buildings and drawing roads.
IGN's Jack Devries added that saving and loading took so long that players would be put off saving at all. In a game that crashes, that's the worst possible combination.
Crashes that decide whether a mission can be finished
The bug reports are specific, and they go well beyond rough edges:
- GameSpot hit a mission that couldn't be completed until the sound effects were turned off, and another that crashed when zooming in or out.
- Pocket Gamer saw icons vanish, attacks on enemies sometimes fail, and stored resources disappear. Zooming right after saving crashed the game.
- IGN reported frequent crashes and called it "not even a functional game."
Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead called it one of the most "clumsy and broken" games ever to get a commercial release.
The scores follow from that. GameSpot gave it 3.5 out of 10, IGN 4 out of 10, Pocket Gamer 1.5 out of 5 and Eurogamer 1 out of 10. Metacritic had it at 39 out of 100 from six reviews. The critic average, calculated from four critic scores, is 2.9 out of 10.
Who this port lets down most
Critics didn't think the design was the problem. Pocket Gamer's Mark Walbank liked the core gameplay, and GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd said that when it works it can be laid-back fun. Whitehead said the game would have been a disappointing but passable conversion without the fatal bugs. The trouble is that a slow economy game asks for hours of patient building, and this version can throw that work away without warning.
Devries made the sharpest point. He said the people most disappointed would be the biggest fans of The Settlers, since they know how good the original is. A port that changed almost nothing only needed to run properly, and by every critic's account this one doesn't.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Settlers DS en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q63985050 wikidata.org