The Shadow of Zorro trades swordplay for stealth on a weak frame
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for Zorro fans who'd rather sneak than duel
The Shadow of Zorro is for a narrow audience: people who love the masked hero and are happy to play him as a spy rather than a swordsman. Developer In Utero built it as a 3D stealth-adventure, and its missions center on spying and rescues instead of open fights.
It came out on January 18, 2002, on PlayStation 2 and Windows. Cryo Interactive published it, and Dreamcatcher Entertainment handled the North American release. It's a single-player game only.
If you want the sword-and-cape Zorro of the films, this isn't quite that game. If you like quiet routes, timing and getting people out alive, the premise suits you better.
There's a lot of it, and much of it is film
The game is bigger than its reputation suggests. It has:
- 7 chapters of story
- 28 different locations
- 700 animated cutscenes
That last number stands out. Seven hundred cutscenes across seven chapters means the story is told largely on film between the stealth sections. For a fan who mainly wants more Zorro, that's the main reason to play. You get plenty of the character, in plenty of places.
The best review on file agrees with that view. One critic scored the PC version 14/20, the highest mark the game has, and the only score behind its critic average.
Where the levels let it down
Stealth games depend on their levels. Guard routes, hiding spots and alternate paths make up the whole game, and that's where critics found it lacking. Futuregamez.net gave it 49% and said it:
"seems very underdeveloped with poor level structures"
That's a serious charge against this kind of game. A shooter with dull maps can still feel good to play. A stealth game with poorly built levels has nothing left to sneak through. Weak levels leave the spying and rescue missions with little to stand on.
The scale also cuts both ways. A game with 700 cutscenes, which a critic still called very underdeveloped, looks like it spent its effort on presentation rather than play. That's a judgment, not a measurement, but it fits what the reviews describe.
Read the 7.0 with care
The critic average of 7.0 comes from a published formula, and here that formula has one critic score to work with: the 14/20 for the PC version. One score doesn't settle much on its own.
The wider reception was generally poor. Futuregamez.net's 49% sits well below that 7.0. Gry Online gave a mixed review, and its clearest praise went to the game's Flash-based website, which it singled out for ingenuity. When a review's warmest words are for the marketing site, the game didn't win the critic over.
So treat the 7.0 as one reviewer's view, not a consensus. The critics who wrote at length mostly agreed that this was an underbuilt stealth game wrapped in a lot of cutscenes.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Shadow of Zorro (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q3204499 wikidata.org