Analysis · The Sims 4

The Sims 4 made its Sims deeper and the world around them thinner

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The same critics praised it and panned it

The biggest split over The Sims 4 isn't between two groups of critics. It runs through single reviews. Nick Tan of GameRevolution called the animation "unbelievable" and praised the stability, then concluded the game was "woefully incomplete". Steve Hogarty of PCGamesN said each Sim had more simulation depth than in The Sims 3, while calling the base game "feature-light and skeletal".

The aggregates show the same tension. Metacritic filed the launch reviews under "mixed or average". One later aggregate of 22 reviews across PC and consoles sits at 76/100, and another of 24 reviews sits at 64/100. The critic average of 7.0 is computed from those critic aggregates, and it lands between the two.

Critics mostly agreed on the facts: the people got better and the world got smaller. Which of those matters more to you decides whether you'll like it.

Why the Sims themselves won critics over

There's no story and no end goal. You guide Sims through six needs (hunger, bladder, hygiene, social, fun and energy), plus jobs, skills and a lifelong aspiration, while the game generates wants and fears as you go. Most of the praise was for changes to that loop.

  • Chris Thursten of PC Gamer said the emotion system "changes the feel and flow" of play.
  • GameSpot's VanOrd called emotions combined with multitasking a "sheer delight".
  • Kallie Plagge of IGN liked that she no longer had to micro-manage every interaction.

The creation tools did well too. In Create-a-Sim you shape faces and bodies by grabbing the part you want to change, and Lee Cooper of Hardcore Gamer called it a "veritable hodgepodge of options". Joystiq's Alexander Sliwinski praised the new search in Build mode. The Gallery, which lets players download shared creations (celebrity lookalikes included), got singled out as well.

Updates kept adding to the core. Toddlers arrived in 2017. Wider gender options came in 2016, a broader range of skin tones in 2020, likes and dislikes in 2021, and custom pronouns in 2022, developed with the It Gets Better Project and GLAAD.

Where the base game came up short

Before launch, Maxis confirmed that swimming pools and toddlers would be missing, along with The Sims 3's open worlds and its Create-a-Style color tool. Players started a petition on Change.org. Maxis said the work on the new engine, the AI simulation and the rebuilt creation modes took the resources those features would have needed.

Critics took the gaps seriously. James Stephanie Sterling of The Escapist called the game "shrunken and sterile". Plagge found fewer furnishing options in Build mode than in The Sims 3. Griffin McElroy of Polygon wrote that a single in-game lifetime showed everything on offer and left no reason to start over. Reviewers also mentioned frequent loading screens and occasional glitches.

Several reviewers suspected the cuts were made to leave room for paid packs. Cooper put it bluntly, calling the game "a glorified freemium app".

The PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions came out in 2017 and drew extra criticism for their controller-based controls, bugs and performance problems.

Free changes who it's for

The base game went free-to-play in October 2022. The breadth critics missed now mostly lives in optional paid packs: expansion and game packs add vampires, mermaids, spellcasters, werewolves and aliens, and Cats & Dogs adds pets. On macOS and Windows, mods and fan-made custom content add even more.

  • Good fit: players who enjoy designing characters and houses and watching moods and relationships play out, and PC players who'll use custom content.
  • Poor fit: fans who want The Sims 3's open neighborhoods and Create-a-Style, console players who want comfortable controller play, and anyone who wants years of variety without paying for packs.

McElroy's one-lifetime complaint works as a test. If a single generation leaves you wanting more, that's the point to look at packs.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet