The Witcher 2 rebuilt its combat and kept the grown-up writing
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The second main game, and a clear break from the first
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings came out on May 17, 2011. It's CD Projekt Red's sequel to the 2007 game The Witcher and the second main game in the series, which is based on Andrzej Sapkowski's fantasy novels. You again play Geralt, a witcher, and the game again mixes swordplay, potions and magic Signs.
The way you play is what changed. The gameplay is a marked departure from the first game, and the change you notice first is combat. Geralt can now lay traps and aim and throw ranged weapons. His kit covers melee and ranged weapons, armor and bombs, along with secondary weapons such as hatchets and shovels. The game also adds stealth in certain parts. You have to reach an objective without being seen, and you can stun a guard by getting behind him. If you'd rather fight the guards openly, the game lets you.
It came out on Windows, Xbox 360, OS X and Linux, and it's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.
Four upgrade paths, and one you can't skip
Character growth is split into four paths, and the order matters:
- Training comes first. It holds general upgrades to core abilities, and you have to put points into it before the other three open.
- Swordsmanship improves Geralt's sword fighting.
- Alchemy includes perks such as reducing the negative effects of potions.
- Magic strengthens the Witcher Signs.
This setup asks you to commit. A sword build and an alchemy build play differently, and critics listed customization among the game's strengths. Requiring Training first also means every Geralt starts from the same base before the build takes shape.
The opening hours are where critics split
Most of the debate was about difficulty, especially in the first hours. Critics generally praised the combat mechanics, but PC Gamer counted combat, along with the ending, among the game's weaker points. Others welcomed the steep start. Eurogamer praised the difficulty of the prologue, arguing that the game treats the player "as an adult" who is free to make mistakes and live with a plot in which not everyone gets what they deserve.
Expect the first stretch to be the hardest part to get through. The reviews that loved this game mostly loved it after that stretch.
1UP's Tom Chick, who gave it an A, pointed to "complex challenging combat" as part of its appeal. If you want fights that ask something of you, read this as a selling point. If you want a gentle on-ramp, read it as a warning.
Writing that treats its world seriously, mostly
The storytelling got the most consistent praise. Chick singled out its "superlative low-fantasy writing" and graphics that work without needing to be flashy. GamePro called it a showcase for what PC development does well, and Game Informer said the dark fantasy adventure held up just as well on console as on PC. Critics also praised the environments and how absorbing the world is.
The same seriousness drew criticism. Rock, Paper, Shotgun called some of the nudity gratuitous, pointing to a scene in which the character Maria Louisa La Valette is threatened with torture. It argued that the nudity sexualizes a moment meant to be grave. Other critics thought the scene was simply realistic. It's one scene, but it shows the risk that comes with the game's adult tone.
How it landed
Aggregate critic scores sit around 90 out of 100 on both Windows and Xbox 360, and one outlet gave it a perfect 5 out of 5. It won more than 50 awards, including best story, best RPG, best PC game and Game of the Year, and the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for its role-playing award. Sales built slowly. It had sold about 940,000 copies by August 2011, 1.7 million by May 2012, and more than 15 million worldwide according to CD Projekt CEO Michał Nowakowski in January 2026.
In short, the sequel kept the first game's mature, morally gray storytelling and rebuilt nearly everything you do with your hands. Critics mostly agreed the trade was worth it.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q917272 wikidata.org