Analysis · The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Witcher 3 is a book of dark fantasy short stories with a sword attached

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea: every side quest is a short story

Critics kept coming back to one point. Tom Senior of GamesRadar called the side quests "a compilation of dark fantasy short stories" and said they overshadowed the main quests. Kimberly Wallace of Game Informer made the same case: each side quest worked like a short story, and the choices made in it changed the state of the world.

That is the idea the game is built on. You play Geralt of Rivia, a monster slayer for hire, and the job is a reason to walk into other people's trouble. Side quests start at a town's noticeboard. Witcher Contracts are longer, more involved monster hunts. A dialogue tree lets you choose how Geralt answers people, and his decisions lead to 36 possible endings that affect the lives of the characters around him.

Each part of the game below is judged against that idea: does it feed the stories, or does it get in their way?

The open world works because it hands out stories

The world passes the test better than anything else in the game. GameTrailers' Daniel Bloodworth praised how many quests only appear after you meet characters in different parts of the map, so exploring means finding new stories rather than ticking off icons. Wallace called the world "immersive" and noted its attention to detail. Destructoid's Chris Carter said it was big enough to take hours to explore.

The world also changes around you. The day-night cycle affects some monsters: a werewolf is strongest on the night of a full moon. An in-game bestiary lets you read up on an enemy before a fight. Vince Ingenito of IGN and Shaun Prescott of PC Gamer both singled out the scenery and the day-night cycle, and Ingenito said they made the world feel authentic.

The weak spot is volume. Jonathon Leack of Game Revolution liked that every region had quests and activities, but thought much of it was filler that stretched the game's length. Where the world feeds a story, critics loved it. Where it pads, they noticed.

The main plot is where the idea thins out

The main story gives Geralt more character than the earlier games did, and critics welcomed that. Kevin Van Ord of GameSpot said it built emotional ties to the cast. Wallace thought the romance options were a big improvement over the series' earlier games. Van Ord, Wallace and Brett Phipps of VideoGamer.com all praised the voice acting, which Wallace called the series' best.

The long main quest got a cooler reception than the short ones around it. Ingenito found too much padding and too many dull quests. Prescott said the narrative would have felt rote if the side content weren't so engaging. Wallace was disappointed by the endings.

Polygon's Arthur Gies raised a different problem: he found some female characters overly sexualized and noted there are no people of color in the main game.

Combat serves the hunts but rarely rises to them

Geralt carries a steel sword for people and a silver one for monsters, plus bombs and a crossbow. He has light and heavy attacks, can block and counter, and has five magic signs, from Aard's telekinetic blast to Quen's temporary shield, which all draw on stamina. Preparation matters: potions, bombs and the bestiary turn a contract into a planned hunt.

Critics split on how it feels.

  • Ingenito praised its fluidity as a big step up from the earlier games.
  • Bloodworth liked the extra mobility from climbing and swimming, both new to the series.
  • Carter enjoyed the action but said the older games' strategy had been stripped out.
  • Wallace found it more accessible but disliked weapon wear and the crossbow aiming.
  • Leack and Senior pointed to an unreliable lock-on, camera trouble, long animations and inconsistent dodging.

The skill trees drew the same split: Ingenito called them deep and flexible, Leack called them "unexciting". Senior found Gwent, the in-game card game, addictive.

Technical problems are the real caveat

Carter reported stiff climbing animations and bugs that could block progress. Wallace found load times too long. Leack said the finished game didn't look as good as the 2013 demo. Senior, Phipps and Ingenito all noted frame rate problems. Ingenito thought they didn't hurt play, but Phipps called them a persistent problem that overshadowed much of what the game gets right.

Platform matters too. On Metacritic, the PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S versions earned "universal acclaim", while the Switch version earned "generally favorable reviews". If you have a choice, the Switch is the version critics rated lowest.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet