The Witcher makes your choices come due acts later, not scenes later
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Choices that come due acts later
The Witcher is built on one idea: a choice should cost you something you can't see yet. Critics kept coming back to it. Michael Lafferty at GameZone gave it 8.8 out of 10 and said the game asks you to "think and make choices" rather than hack your way through. It's based on Andrzej Sapkowski's fantasy novels and set after the events of the main saga. You play Geralt of Rivia, one of a few traveling monster hunters with supernatural powers, known as Witchers.
The mechanism is a time-delayed decision-consequence system. What you decide in one act shows up as a plot turn in a later one, long after the moment has passed. That gap is the point. Reloading a save to fix a bad call stops being practical when you won't learn it was bad until a later act.
The choices themselves are rarely clean. Geralt is often picking the lesser of two evils, so the system never turns into a hunt for the right answer. It also gives the game its replay value, because different decisions can lead to very different events later on.
Combat asks you to read the enemy first
The fights test the same idea on a smaller scale. Geralt has three fighting styles, and you can switch between them at any moment:
- Fast: quicker, lighter attacks with a better chance of hitting fast enemies.
- Strong: heavier damage, but slower swings and worse odds against quick foes.
- Group: sweeping attacks for when Geralt is surrounded.
On top of that is the two-sword rule. The steel blade is for humans and other flesh-and-blood enemies. The silver sword is for supernatural monsters and beasts, and against some of them steel may do nothing at all. Precisely timed attacks link into combos. Together, these make a fight a run of small calls about what you're facing, which suits the game's central idea better than raw reflexes would.
You can play from two isometric views, where the mouse handles most functions, or from an over-the-shoulder view that brings you closer to the fighting but narrows what you can see. In each view, the controls can be mostly mouse or a keyboard-and-mouse mix.
Alchemy turns preparation into a gamble
Alchemy is a major system, and it's where the idea of choices with a price is most literal. Potions can speed up health or endurance regeneration, let Geralt see in the dark, or give other benefits. You learn recipes from scrolls or by experimenting, and experiments can go wrong: drink an unknown potion that turns out to be a failure and it can poison Geralt.
Even good potions have a cost. Each one raises the toxicity level in Geralt's body. Only a special potion or meditating at an inn or fireplace brings it back down. Oils that add weapon damage and bombs for combat fill out the kit, but you can't make either until you've put talent points into the matching skills.
What these systems teach: prepare before the fight, because what Geralt drinks and carries has consequences too.
Critics rewarded the patience
Reviews were mostly positive. The game's cumulative score on Metacritic stands at 81 out of 100. The one critic score listed for this edition is 86/100 for the Windows version, and the critic average of 8.6 is computed from it. GameZone's Lafferty called the game deep and immersive.
Recognition went beyond reviews. The cinematic intro was nominated at the 2007 VES Awards for Outstanding Pre-Rendered Visuals in a Video Game. The soundtrack was voted "Best Fantasy Game Soundtrack" at the 2007 Radio Rivendell Fantasy Awards. The Academy of Interactive Arts and Sciences nominated it for 2007's Role-Playing Game of the Year, which went to Mass Effect. In 2010, it was included in the book 1001 Video Games You Must Play Before You Die.
It has also lasted. In 2026, CD Projekt co-CEO Michał Nowakowski said The Witcher had sold over 10 million copies worldwide and was still selling. What critics praised is the same thing the design is built around: the game trusts you to make a call and live with it.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Witcher: Enhanced Edition en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q110752642 wikidata.org