This Zelda sequel keeps the old map and hands you the tools to rebuild it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel that reuses Hyrule on purpose
Tears of the Kingdom is the direct follow-up to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (2017), and it doesn't hide it. It came out for the Nintendo Switch on May 12, 2023. The open-world Hyrule is back, along with the climbing, the horse riding and the paraglider. Many characters and places return too, reworked for a new story in which Link searches for Princess Zelda and fights to stop Ganondorf from destroying the kingdom.
That reuse was the bet. Instead of drawing a new map, the developers stacked new areas above and below the old one and changed how Link handles everything in it. Many critics judged the result equal to or better than Breath of the Wild, and Metacritic reports that the Switch version received "universal acclaim". The critic average, which is calculated from critic scores, is 9.4 out of 10.
Game Informer added a fair caveat. The game can't recreate the surprise of seeing this world for the first time, but it offers something different: the pull of seeing familiar ground changed.
Building replaced the old toolkit
The biggest change is in Link's hands. Breath of the Wild's Sheikah Slate abilities are gone, replaced by five powers:
- Ultrahand picks up objects and sticks them together. It's how you build vehicles from Zonai devices such as rockets, sleds and fans.
- Fuse attaches materials and objects to a weapon or shield. Fuse a rocket to a shield and it launches Link into the air.
- Ascend takes him straight up through solid ceilings.
- Recall rewinds an object's movement, so a falling rock can carry you upward.
- Autobuild rebuilds an Ultrahand design you've made before and makes any missing parts from a material called zonaite.
Critics liked the powers more than anything else in the game. GamesRadar+ called them well designed and singled out Ultrahand, and GameSpot rated them above the previous game's abilities. Polygon compared Ascend to a noclip mode and the other powers to cheat codes, and said learning them was one of the main draws. The Guardian liked that nearly any obstacle can be handled several ways.
The same praise has a catch. GamesRadar+ noted that some powers feel like gaming the system, and that breaking the rules this easily can make the game less satisfying. If you like puzzles with one clean answer, that freedom cuts both ways.
Two new layers, and no agreement on the better one
Above Hyrule float sky islands full of puzzles, treasure, enemies and bosses. Below it lies the Depths, a dark region where you need light to see. Its hazards include lava and gloom, a substance that cuts Link's maximum hearts until he returns to the surface. Reviewers praised both areas, plus the new caves, for making the world bigger in ways that matter.
They disagreed about which layer works best. Eurogamer preferred the skies, whose designs reminded it of Skyward Sword and The Wind Waker. It also said you could spend all your time in the Depths if the surface didn't keep drawing you back for tools. Video Games Chronicle took the opposite view: it found the Depths harder and more fun, and said the sky leaned on story. Nintendo Life said the three areas connect well despite their different rules.
The old collecting loop is still here. Every four Lights of Blessing from Shrines buy more hearts or stamina, and Korok seeds still add slots for weapons, shields and bows.
A stronger story, let down by how it's told
Critics thought the story improved most over Breath of the Wild. GameSpot ranked it among the best in the series. Nintendo Life found the characters more engaging, both in the main story and in the side quests. Destructoid called the pacing faster, though it faulted some parts. VG247 disagreed, saying the story mattered less than the gameplay and got repetitive because you can tackle it in any order.
Two complaints come up again and again. Polygon counted the dungeons that carry the story (the Water Temple, Wind Temple, Fire Temple and Lightning Temple) among the weak spots, saying they limit your freedom and that Link's allies talk too much. The voice acting also drew criticism. GamesRadar+ said the characters sounded disconnected from their roles. VG247 agreed but felt the music and atmosphere saved the cutscenes.
The Switch is the ceiling
Performance drew the most consistent criticism. Nintendo Life said the game showed the Switch's limits with frame rate drops, though it called the problem minor. Polygon noted a poor frame rate and load times in some areas, much like in Breath of the Wild. IGN saw no improvement in performance but felt it hardly mattered given the quality of the rest. GameSpot found slowdowns rare and said the art style hides the loss in detail.
The game is also listed for Nintendo Switch 2, but the critics' performance complaints in the record are about the original Switch. It was also the first Nintendo-developed game priced at US$70.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q64577191 wikidata.org