Analysis · Super Mario 3D All-Stars

Three classic 3D Mario games, preserved more than remade, on one Switch cart

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for fans who want the originals, not reinventions

This collection is for players who already love Super Mario 64 (1996), Super Mario Sunshine (2002) and Super Mario Galaxy (2007), or who want to play them for the first time on the Switch. Nintendo released it on September 18, 2020, for the series' 35th anniversary. All three are ports in high definition, and critics agreed the games underneath are as good as ever.

Players hoping for a modern rebuild should look elsewhere. IGN's Zachary Ryan said the use of emulation explains "a lot about the lack of upgrades" in each game. He compared it unfavorably with the "major overhauls" Nintendo once gave older games in Super Mario All-Stars. Metacritic lists the reviews as "generally favorable", and OpenCritic reports that 85% of critics recommended it. Most of the criticism was about the packaging, not the games inside it.

Super Mario 64 is the strongest port

Critics were most positive about the oldest game. Kotaku's Ian Walker found the port free of "obviously unfortunate consequences" and said it even fixed some performance dips from the original. Ryan thought the upscaling made it look better than it ever had and called the controls "still super tight" on either Switch controller.

There were two catches. At launch the camera's horizontal controls were inverted, though a later patch made that optional. Ryan also warned that newcomers "might find it somewhat inaccessible" with no quality-of-life changes. A game from 1996 plays like one, and nothing here eases that.

Sunshine and Galaxy carry the rough edges

The two later games had more trouble moving to new hardware, mostly because of their original controls.

  • Super Mario Sunshine: Walker said the adjusted controls would trip up anyone with muscle memory from the original, and he noted visual stutter late in the game. Ryan also reported slowdown at certain moments, though he still called it a fantastic-looking game with fluid controls.
  • Super Mario Galaxy: Some motion controls were moved to buttons, which Walker welcomed. Areas that still need motion controls were as awkward as they had been on the Wii, he said. Ryan called the upscaled version "a fully realized version" of the game and liked the new control options, but said handheld mode, while workable, is "not the most ideal way to play".

Sunshine draws the most mixed notes of the three. Galaxy looks the best of the three but can feel awkward to play.

What critics wanted from the collection

The common complaint was that a 35th-anniversary release could have offered more. Critics pointed to its simple presentation, the lack of extra features and the decision to sell it for a limited time only. Many also noted that Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010) was left out, even though it would have fit alongside the first Galaxy.

The games hold up. The package around them is the thin part.

None of that changes the three games, which critics still rated highly. It does mean the collection's value comes almost entirely from the games themselves. If you already own the originals and the hardware to play them, there's little new here beyond high-definition visuals and the convenience of playing on the Switch.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet