Three Kingdoms wins on its generals' grudges more than on its battlefields
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics loved the people and doubted the battles
The highest praise for Total War: Three Kingdoms comes close to unqualified. Chris Wray of wccftech called it "as close to flawless" as strategy gets, pointing to how it balances 4X empire building with character-focused storytelling. IGN's TJ Hafer went further and argued that every game in the genre should follow its example from now on.
The sharpest criticism is aimed at the other half of the game. PCGamesN's Phil Iwaniuk called the campaign memorable but said the real-time battles lack the depth of earlier entries in the series. PC Gamer's Jody Macgregor also liked the campaign, but felt the game couldn't break away from problems the series has always had. Macgregor placed it well short of the best Total War and well clear of the worst.
So the split is clear. The strategy map and its characters drew wide praise, and most of the doubts gathered on the battlefield. The numbers side with the praise: critic aggregates came in at 85/100 from 69 reviews and 82/100 from 17, with a 93% figure across 70 reviews. The critic average, which is computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.4.
Generals with grudges drive the campaign
The game is set at the end of the Han dynasty (189-220) and runs into the Three Kingdoms era (220–280). You lead a faction under a warlord such as Cao Cao, Liu Bei or Sun Quan. The goal is to eliminate or vassalize rivals until you have enough prestige to declare yourself Emperor. Then you still have to defeat the two other Emperors and unify China.
What sets it apart is guanxi, the web of relationships between characters. Generals value obligations, reciprocity and trust, and each one has a personality and wants of their own. Ignore those wants and their happiness drops, which can cause trouble later. In earlier Total War games, characters rarely dealt with each other. Here they form relationships with the people they meet across the campaign, so you have to know your officers before you make a move.
This is the part critics singled out most. The Guardian's Edwin Evans-Thirlwell said the game understands that the best stories are about "people, not empires." Getting people at the center of a grand strategy map is the game's real achievement, and it's the reason to pick it up.
Romance mode is the better way in
The game has two modes, and they play differently:
- Romance draws on the novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Generals have nearly superhuman strength, can be commanded apart from their troops and can fight one-on-one duels that end when one dies or flees. Killed generals drop gear you can loot, so Lü Bu's Red Hare can end up under one of your own officers.
- Records draws on Records of the Three Kingdoms and aims for historical accuracy. Generals lose their powers, can't be commanded separately, and some equipment is changed to match the period.
Reviewers kept comparing Romance to Total War: Warhammer. Preston Dozsa of CGMagazine said the game brings together the best of the series' historical and fantasy sides. Sean Martin of Hooked Gamers called it the most different Total War since Warhammer, using fantasy to support the history rather than replace it.
Romance is where the game feels most like itself, because the hero generals give the guanxi system real weight on the battlefield. Records is there for players who want the history played straight, and the praise on record mostly isn't about that mode.
Battles look great but don't go deep
Armies are organized into retinues, each led by a general. You can field up to three generals at once, with three more in reserve, and you can only use the units those generals are able to recruit. A siege is won by killing every enemy general or by capturing the center of the city. Each general's class and specialty give their units active and passive buffs.
Iwaniuk's complaint is that all of this adds up to less than earlier Total War battles offered. Even so, the battles had their admirers. Denis Ryan of Rock, Paper, Shotgun noted that the game borrows from many of Creative Assembly's past games, yet no other game combines those elements in quite the same way, and no other strategy game looks this good.
Eurogamer's Chris Tapsell called it "ambitious and sometimes overwhelming."
That warning matters for newcomers. Between the relationships, the two modes and the retinue rules, there's a lot to learn. Beifang Lin of the Chinese outlet GamerSky praised the team's grasp of the era and said the setting fits the Total War formula well. The setting is a big part of why the game is worth that learning time.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Total War: Three Kingdoms en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q48928832 wikidata.org