Three PS2 Ratchet & Clank games that critics said still play well in HD
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics loved the games and shrugged at the remaster
The strongest praise came from Eurogamer. It gave the collection 9/10 and said criticisms were "hard to find and even harder to make stick." The sharpest criticism points somewhere else entirely. Several reviewers faulted the graphics for looking aged and said the package didn't offer anything new.
Both camps were reviewing the same thing. The games underneath held up well. The remaster work on top was thin. Most outlets decided the first mattered more, which is why the collection averages 83 out of 100 on Metacritic from 40 critics, and why the critic average works out to 8.1.
The controls aged better than the visuals
Critics agreed most on the gameplay. IGN scored the collection 8.5 out of 10 and gave the gameplay particular credit. Digital Spy gave it four out of five stars and said the gameplay hadn't aged. The Guardian said the games had held up and called the bundle great value.
Game Informer was the most enthusiastic, at 9.25 out of 10. It singled out the control system in Up Your Arsenal, which suggests the third game in the set is the best one to play now. For a compilation of games first made for the PlayStation 2, that agreement on feel and handling is the best reason to buy it.
Stereoscopic 3D got most of the attention, and Gaming Bolt dissented
Most of the praise focused on the collection's stereoscopic 3D mode, which reviewers said made the games feel more dynamic. In 2012 it was the clearest sign that the remaster was more than an upscale.
Gaming Bolt didn't agree. It was one of the few outlets to review the 3D options in detail, and it found them stable but said they added nothing to the collection. It also questioned why the feature was included. If you don't have a 3D display, you lose the feature critics talked about most, and the remaster gets thinner still.
A faithful remaster, dated cut-scenes included
Critics disagreed about how the games look. Digital Spy credited Idol Minds with graphics that were "equally good" next to the gameplay. Other reviewers called the visuals aged and poor. The PlayStation Official Magazine - UK gave the collection 8 out of 10 but criticized it for keeping the cut-scenes and gameplay in their original format and resolution.
The magazine also praised one addition. The collection includes the multiplayer, which many PlayStation 2 owners had missed the first time.
Bonus material is thin. Digital Spy said series fans would have liked more of it. Expect the three games in high definition and little else: no making-of extras and no new content.
Pick the PS3 version over the Vita port
Mass Media ported the collection to PlayStation Vita in 2014, and critics rated the port lower. It averages 76 on Metacritic from 23 critic reviews, against 83 for PlayStation 3. Reviews of the Vita version were still mostly positive. Even so, the gap is wide enough to buy the PS3 version if you have the choice.
The same games, rated seven points lower on a handheld.
The collection carries Teen and PEGI 7 ratings, so check which one applies where you live before handing it to younger players.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Ratchet & Clank Collection en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2075684 wikidata.org