Thronefall puts the king on the battlefield, and critics barely argued about it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The biggest disagreement is a single point
Critics barely disagreed about Thronefall. Metacritic counted four reviews and scored both the Nintendo Switch and Microsoft Windows versions at 85/100, which it labels "critical acclaim." A second aggregate tracked nine reviews as of October 24, 2024. It gave the game 86/100 and a 100% rating. The widest gap between the published scores is one point.
The number of reviews matters more than the scores. Four reviews on one aggregate and nine on the other is a small panel for a game that sold just under 1 million copies in a year. A consensus among a handful of critics is real, but it doesn't tell you much. It shows that the people who reviewed the game liked it, but not where it falls short. The critic average of 8.6 out of 10 is computed from those aggregates, so it has the same limit.
Thronefall came out in early access on Windows on August 2, 2023. The full version arrived on Windows and Nintendo Switch on October 11, 2024, and an iOS version followed in June 2025.
What critics agreed on: a king who fights
The one detailed critical take comes from Try Hard, which rated the game 10/10. It praised three things:
- a player-controlled ruler who fights next to computer-controlled troops
- the depth of the customization options and unlockables
- the building upgrades
Its summary was that the game gives "new meaning to 'replayability.'"
That praise matches how the game is built. Each level centers on a great hall that the monarch has to protect. During the day, you spend gold on walls, defensive towers, homes, farmland, mines and fisheries. You also recruit crossbowmen and knights at barracks and post them where the kingdom needs them. When you're ready, you call in the night and the enemy waves arrive. The monarch joins the fight with a bow or a spear, and each weapon has its own special ability.
Why the loop keeps pulling you back
What happens after each night explains Try Hard's praise for replay value. When you defeat every enemy, all destroyed buildings and units come back. You're also paid gold based on how many buildings survived the attack. A rough night doesn't snowball into a ruined kingdom, and a tight defense pays off directly in the next day's budget.
Every building either earns gold or protects the gold you've earned, and your reward depends on how much of it is still standing at dawn.
That makes the design compact. Farms, mines and fisheries pay for the economy, while walls, towers and soldiers keep it standing. Players who like reworking a layout to get a better result will find that the structure rewards it on every level. Players hoping for a sprawling city to run will find a short list of buildings, all there to protect one hall. Thronefall counts as a city-builder because you place farms and walls, not because you manage a city.
Who the praise actually applies to
No critic argued against Thronefall, so the useful question is which players the praise applies to. Based on what critics praised, it fits these players best:
- Tower defense fans who want to fight on the field, not just place towers and watch.
- Strategy players who replay levels to improve, since unlockables and upgrades are the reward.
- Players who want a single-player game. That's the only mode it has.
Players who want a long story, multiplayer or a detailed city simulation should hold back. None of those show up in the game's description, and with so few reviews, no critic offers evidence that they're there.
For everyone else, the scores send one clear signal, even if it comes from only a few reviewers.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Thronefall en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q121177484 wikidata.org