Analysis · Mario vs. Donkey Kong: Tipping Stars

Tipping Stars is a solid Minis puzzler whose namesake feature went offline

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

You build the road and the Minis walk it

You don't steer Mario in Tipping Stars. You steer the floor under him. Wind-up Minis march across each level on their own, and your job is to shape their route with the 3DS touchscreen or the Wii U GamePad. Each level gives you up to four kinds of item, such as red pathways and springs, to lay down so the Minis reach the Goal Door safely and stay together.

Small mistakes end a run. If a Mini touches an enemy or spikes, gets left behind, or the timer runs out, the level is over. That pressure is the heart of the game. You're placing pieces quickly while the Minis keep walking, and every second you save becomes points.

When the Minis get through, the time left on the clock is added to your score. That score decides your trophy and how many stars you earn, so finishing a level and finishing it well are separate goals.

A return to the side view, minus the boss fights

After Minis on the Move, this sixth game in the Mario vs. Donkey Kong series goes back to the two-dimensional side view and plays like Mini-Land Mayhem. Fans of that game will feel at home right away. Critics noticed the same thing, and they meant it both as praise and as complaint.

The one big change to the structure is that bosses are gone. In their place are ordinary levels with a Cursed Mini Mario wandering through them, which keeps the focus on routing puzzles instead of switching to fights.

There's a lot here once the main levels are done:

  • Clearing every level unlocks two extra worlds.
  • Three Bonus worlds open one at a time as you collect gold trophies.
  • Both versions have the same levels, and the 3DS layouts are adjusted slightly to fit its smaller touchscreen.

It was also the first game Nintendo published with cross-purchase. Buying one version got you a free download code for the other.

The feature in the title no longer works

Stars are the game's currency. You spend them on items for the built-in level creator, and some of those items can't be bought just by finishing the game normally. The idea was that the community would fill that gap. Players could rate each other's levels through Miiverse by tipping stars, and leave messages with stamps.

Those online services shut down along with Miiverse in November 2017. Without them, the tipping system, the shared levels and the stamps are all gone. Nintendo kept selling the game until the Nintendo eShop closed, but the part that made it more than a level pack hasn't worked for years.

The level creator itself still works, so you can still build levels. What's missing is anyone to play them and the stars that sharing used to earn.

Critics liked the puzzles more than the familiar formula

Reviews were mixed but not harsh. The Wii U version has a Metacritic score of 70/100. OpenCritic counted only 38% of critics recommending it, which shows how many reviewers called it fine but not essential. The critic average of 7.2 out of 10 is calculated from those critic aggregates.

IGN gave it a 6.8/10. It praised the challenge and the large amount of content, and complained that there were few new ideas. Electronic Gaming Monthly also criticized the lack of innovation, but concluded that the formula was solid, simple and fun, and that it's what makes the series recognizable in its genre.

The critics agreed on one thing: the puzzles hold up, and the game rarely surprises you.

On longevity, the single-player content is the most reliable part. It has a main set of worlds, two post-game worlds and three trophy-gated Bonus worlds, and the scoring system rewards replaying levels for gold. With its online community gone, the game is best judged on those offline puzzles alone.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet