Analysis · Too Human

Too Human pairs a bold Norse sci-fi world with combat critics fought over

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A striking premise held back by a stubborn control scheme

At its best, critics found a lot to admire. The game retells Norse mythology as science fiction: the Æsir are cybernetically enhanced humans defending mankind from Loki's army of machines. X-Play admitted the mix "sounds like a stretch" but decided that "on the whole, it works." IGN called the music and voice acting "top-notch" and said the game did a good job of keeping players engrossed.

The sharpest criticism hit what you do most often, which is fight. GameTrailers called the right-stick combat "broken" and compared it to button mashing. GameDaily went further and named Too Human its "Underperformer of the Year," saying it had expected better from such a long development. Between those two poles sits a game that critics averaged at 65/100 on Metacritic and 68.59% on GameRankings.

The right stick swings the sword, not the camera

You play Baldur, a god who is less cybernetic than the rest, which is why he is "too human." The camera sits in a third-person view. You can adjust its distance, but you don't steer it freely, because the right analog stick is for melee attacks. Push it toward an enemy to strike, then keep flicking to chain combos, launch foes into the air, slide into attacks and juggle enemies with ranged fire. Guns use automatic lock-on. Ruiner attacks add area damage and can lead into finishing strikes.

Reviewers were split on this design:

  • GamePro felt it made combat more "slick."
  • Game Informer liked the idea but said it made the camera and the lock-on for ranged weapons worse.
  • Most critics disliked giving up manual camera control.

The objection is reasonable. In a game built on crowd fights, the camera decides what you can see, and taking it out of the player's hands is a real cost.

Where the depth lives: classes, loot and alignment

Its role-playing systems are the game's strongest case, even though critics talked about them less than the controls. At the start you pick one of five classes:

  • Berserker, built for melee
  • Commando, built for ranged combat
  • Bio engineer, with strong healing
  • Defender, with heavy armor
  • Champion, an all-rounder with air strikes

There are fifteen weapon classes, from pistols and heavy lasers to dual and two-handed weapons, plus armor for each body part and charms that power Ruiner abilities. Back at Asgard between levels, you can buy gear and change its color and power with collectible runes. You level up by killing goblins, trolls, dark elves and undead and by landing long combos, then spend points in a class-specific skill tree. Early on you also choose an alignment. Cybernetic opens heavy lasers and more implants, while Human favors faster movement and better combos. That gives players good reasons to play the campaign more than once.

Strong first impressions that wear thin

GameSpot praised the environments for their detail and lighting, from huge statues to light falling on snow. It also said "each setting seems much like the last" and that stiff combat and facial animations stood out more as the game went on. Game Revolution agreed, saying the first level starts strongly before things become too familiar.

Dying was a common complaint. Each time Baldur falls, a Valkyrie collects his body, and critics found the sequence far too long. Official Xbox Magazine called it a "sheer annoyance," and TeamXbox joked about how much shorter the game would be if it could be skipped. Official Xbox Magazine UK also found it frustrating but noted that it stops players from abusing respawns. Eurogamer named the game's biggest problem as its short length for the genre.

Better with a second player

1UP.com and other critics found co-op made the game more fun. Edge agreed but added a pointed observation: many of the game's problems "wouldn't exist" with more players, and the game was originally meant to support four-player multiplayer, which didn't make the final release. In the shipped game, a partner helps cover the camera and repetition problems instead of fixing them.

If you're going to play Too Human, plan on playing it in co-op.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet