Analysis · The Legend of Zelda: Tri Force Heroes

Tri Force Heroes stacks three players into a totem pole and needs all three

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Three heroes, one totem pole

Every level starts the same way. Three players each control a different-colored version of Link, and each gets an item at the start. Nobody can clear the puzzles alone. Each item is there to help the other two get through, and the team has to work out who does what.

The signature move is the totem pole. Players stack on top of each other, and the one on top can reach higher ledges, hit enemies that are otherwise out of reach, or get thrown across a gap. A lot of the puzzles come down to who stands where in the stack and when to break it apart.

The team also shares one heart meter. When it runs out, the team loses one of its life fairies, so one careless player costs all three. That design leans hard toward cooperation, and it's the main thing that sets this game apart from Four Swords and Four Swords Adventures, the series' earlier multiplayer entries. Those supported four players. This one supports three and puts teamwork ahead of competition.

Talking through a handful of icons

The game supports local and online play. Instead of voice chat, players talk by tapping icons on the touch screen, which keeps things simple but limits how much a team can plan. For players who'd rather fight each other, there's a competitive Coliseum mode.

Online play is where critics found the most problems. Many reviewers criticized the online features and the matchmaking, which matters a lot in a game that depends on finding two partners. With a friend sitting next to you, the icons are just a backup. With strangers, they're all you've got.

Playing alone means steering the Doppels

A single player can get through the game by controlling doll-like companions called Doppels in place of the other two players. That means solving three-person puzzles by moving each body in turn. Critics singled out the single-player mode as a weak point.

The bigger problem is the gap in the middle. The main mode doesn't support two players without a third, and many reviewers criticized the missing two-player option. A pair of friends can't just pick it up and play together.

The rule of thumb: count your players before you buy. Three is the game as designed. One works with compromises. Two doesn't work in the main mode.

Costumes, the Den of Trials and a borrowed art style

Players collect items and use them to craft outfits. Costumes are the game's main form of progression. Each one grants a special or hidden ability, like a stronger version of an item, more health or more stamina. Picking outfits that cover each other's weaknesses gives a team something to plan around beyond the puzzles.

Nintendo added a free dungeon, the Den of Trials, on December 2, 2015, along with two more costumes. It has more stages than the original dungeons, and a team can't move on from a stage until every enemy is defeated. That gives teams who've finished the main game a longer, combat-heavy challenge.

The visual style mixes A Link Between Worlds with The Wind Waker, and critics praised the presentation and the soundtrack. The game was winning awards before release, too: at E3 2015 it took the Game Critics Awards prize for Best Handheld/Mobile Game and IGN's Best 3DS Game award.

Good scores, few recommendations

Metacritic called the reviews "mixed or average." One aggregate of 50 reviews came out at 73/100, and another, from eight reviews, at 74/100. The critic average of 7.4, computed from those critic aggregates, lands in the same place.

The more telling number is that OpenCritic found only 35% of critics recommended it. Solid scores alongside a low recommendation rate fit the pattern in the reviews. Critics enjoyed what the game does well, but they hesitated to recommend it to everyone, because its best version depends on having two other people ready to play.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet