Analysis · Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze

Tropical Freeze is a hard, handsome platformer that split its critics

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A perfect 10 and a 6 for the same levels

Destructoid gave Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze a perfect 10 out of 10. GameSpot's original Wii U review gave it 6. Both reviews looked at the same seven islands of side-scrolling levels, and GameSpot's complaint went straight at the thing other critics loved most: it called the level design "clunky, repetitive" and said the new mechanics were poorly implemented.

Nearly everyone else sided with Destructoid. IGN gave it 9 out of 10 for its challenge, level design and boss battles. Game Informer gave it 9.25 for its levels, gameplay and graphics. GameTrailers gave it 9.1 and called the soundtrack "stellar". The 2014 Golden Joystick Awards nominated it for Best Visual Design and Best Audio, so the praise for how it looks and sounds went beyond individual reviewers.

The split matters less than it first seems. When the Nintendo Switch version arrived in May 2018, GameSpot reviewed it again and gave it 9 out of 10. The outlet that criticized it hardest ended up agreeing with everyone else.

Four Kongs, four ways through a level

Tropical Freeze is a direct sequel to the 2010 Wii game Donkey Kong Country Returns. Donkey Kong and his friends cross seven islands to defeat the Snowmads. You mainly control Donkey Kong, with a partner riding along who adds an ability. A second player can also take control of that partner.

  • Diddy Kong uses a barrel jet pack to cross wide gaps.
  • Dixie Kong spins her ponytail like a propeller, gets a small boost at the start and then floats down slowly, which gets you to high platforms and items.
  • Cranky Kong bounces on his walking stick across spiky thorns and other dangerous surfaces, reaches higher areas and beats some enemies the others can't.

Donkey Kong can also pull items out of the ground and pick up stunned enemies to throw them. Filling the Kong-POW meter triggers a team move that clears every enemy on screen and turns them into items. Each level hides Kong letters and puzzle pieces, and some of them need a specific partner to reach. That gives you a reason to replay levels after the credits. Time Attack has online leaderboards with video replays of the top players.

That variety helps explain why GameTrailers praised the enhancements to the gameplay. It also helps explain why GameSpot's first review stood out: the critic who disliked the new mechanics was rejecting the feature most others counted in the game's favor.

Hard on purpose, with an easier mode in the newer port

Critics agreed that the game is difficult. They disagreed about whether that was good. GamesRadar and IGN praised the challenge. GamesTM gave it 7 out of 10 and found it as tough as the earlier games, pointing to how enemies and obstacles are placed and to the hard boss battles.

The Wii U version drops the Super Guide from Returns. In its place is a bigger shop, run by Funky Kong, that sells support items such as temporary invincibility. That gives struggling players some help without the game finishing a level for them.

The Switch version goes further with an optional, easier Funky Mode. Funky Kong plays without a partner and has:

  • five hit points instead of Donkey Kong's usual two
  • a double jump and a mid-air hover
  • the ability to stand on spikes
  • unlimited time underwater

If you switch to Donkey Kong in this mode, each Kong has three hit points. IGN kept its 9 out of 10 for the Switch release. It said Funky Mode makes the game more accessible without reducing the tough platforming difficulty. That is the main reason to choose the Switch version over the Wii U original.

Where even the fans found fault

Critics who liked the game still had reservations. GamesRadar gave it 4 out of 5 stars but criticized the co-op multiplayer. Game Informer noted that it has fewer levels than Returns, even while scoring it 9.25. If you're looking for a game to play with a partner, those two points deserve more weight than the high scores suggest.

The difficulty is the game. Critics praised it and criticized it for the same reason, so how you handle hard platforming should decide whether you buy it.

The age ratings are Everyone and PEGI 3, but that doesn't mean it's easy. On Wii U, younger players will probably find it frustrating. On Switch, Funky Mode makes it a much better fit for a family.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet