Analysis · Fire Emblem Echoes: Shadows of Valentia

Two heroes, one war, and a 1992 rulebook brought back on purpose

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One war, two answers to it

The game rests on one idea: a single war seen through two leaders who disagree about how to end it. Alm fights to settle it on the battlefield. Celica looks for a peaceful end with guidance from the Goddess Mila. You command both armies as they move across the continent of Valentia, and critics judged nearly everything else by how well the game serves that split.

The story held up best. Daan Koopman of Nintendo World Report admired the tension between the two leaders' views on the war. Javy Gwaltney of Game Informer said Alm and Celica were the main reason to keep going. Chris Schilling of GamesRadar called Celica's half the better part of the game. Nobody claimed the premise was new. Ray Carsillo of Electronic Gaming Monthly called it a typical tale of kings, queens, dragons and magic, and Meghan Sullivan of IGN said the story still "makes for a good soap opera."

The supporting cast is weaker. Chris Carter of Destructoid liked the story's large scope and grounded tone but found the cast thinner than in earlier Fire Emblem games. Morgan Sleeper of Nintendo Life saw a simpler story as a plus after the complicated structure of Fates.

Old rules, kept because the source had them

Echoes is the fifteenth Fire Emblem game and a remake of Fire Emblem Gaiden, the 1992 Famicom game that was second in the series. It keeps Gaiden's oddities instead of smoothing them into the modern formula:

  • There's no Weapon Triangle, the rock-paper-scissors system other entries use to decide which weapons beat which.
  • Weapons don't wear out. Each unit carries one, and it learns Combat Arts, special moves that range from heavy hits to swapping places with an ally.
  • Mages pay for every spell with some of their own health.
  • Villagers recruited in towns start weak but can be trained into any available class.

Critics mostly backed the choice. Famitsu said the new and updated mechanics lifted Gaiden out of its old black-sheep status. Griffin Vacheron of GameRevolution found the old systems reworked to feel satisfying. Sullivan described an initial shock that gave way to enjoyment. Several reviewers warned that players coming from Awakening would need time to adjust to the missing Weapon Triangle.

Dungeons give the march a second rhythm

Between battles you move across a world map, visit towns with shops, and enter 3D dungeons with a party of 10. In a dungeon you can dodge enemies, break crates for money and items, and fight on the usual top-down grid when an enemy catches you. Every fight there adds Fatigue and lowers a unit's maximum health until you hand out gifts or purify the unit at a statue. That keeps you from leaning on the same few fighters.

Critics generally liked the dungeons. Vacheron was the exception and found them thin. The battle maps divided reviewers more: Schilling called the map design weak and Sleeper praised much of it. Carsillo enjoyed the combat but noticed that most victory conditions are the same.

Where the difficulty breaks the spell

Here is the clearest trade-off. Gwaltney described points where the difficulty turned unfair and spoiled the better parts of the battles. Sullivan also flagged several unfair spikes. Heidi Kemps of GameSpot enjoyed the combat but noted that grinding was required to get past the hardest fights.

The game does offer relief. There are Normal and Hard settings, and Classic Mode makes fallen units die for good, though a limited number can be revived. Casual Mode brings everyone back after each battle. The new feature is Mila's Turnwheel, which rewinds turns a limited number of times, anywhere from one unit's move back to the start of the fight. Kemps singled it out as a welcome addition.

If a map feels unfair, critics suggest the problem is the map, not you. That's what the Turnwheel is for.

Presentation that sells the drama

Famitsu credited the voice acting and the more action-heavy story scenes with making the drama land. Carsillo praised the full-motion cutscenes and character portraits, and Sullivan called the cutscenes "well-made." Koopman went further and named the visuals the game's biggest step up from earlier 3DS games.

Not everyone agreed. Gwaltney found the character models "a bit fuzzy," Schilling thought the muted colors looked like the product of a smaller budget, and Carter called the voice acting uneven while most others praised it.

Critics landed on 81/100 at Metacritic, and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.1 out of 10. The game was nominated for Best 3DS Game in IGN's Best of 2017 Awards.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet