Ultra Smash nails the rallies and leaves little else on the court
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics agreed on the rallies and argued about everything else
The biggest split over Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash wasn't about how it plays. It was about whether the way it plays is enough. Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard praised the core game, the new HD graphics and the music, calling it a "fun, silly take on tennis." IGN's Marty Sliva gave it 4.8 out of 10 and called it "bare-bones" and "lackluster." GameSpot's Scott Butterworth landed in between at 6 out of 10, faulting the lack of modes and alternate ways to play.
Even the harshest reviews rarely attack the rallies. Their complaint is how little surrounds them. Across 46 reviews, the aggregate settled at 56/100, which works out to a critic average of 5.6 out of 10.
What happens on the court
You pick from 16 playable characters and choose 1-on-1 singles or 2-on-2 doubles. Each court has a different surface, which changes how fast the ball travels and how it bounces. Four mechanics shape a match:
- Chance Shots: glowing spots appear on the ground, and standing on one and pressing the right button combination fires off a powerful shot.
- Jump Shots: you leap to hit the ball, which makes the shot faster and longer.
- Ultra Smash: a special Jump Shot you only get when your opponent loses form while returning a shot. It punishes a sloppy return with a very fast smash.
- Mega Mushroom: it gets thrown onto either side of the court and makes whoever grabs it grow, so they hit harder and farther.
Motion controls are optional. If the gimmicks aren't for you, Classic Tennis lets you turn off Chance Shots, Jump Shots or Mega Mushrooms, which gets you close to the series before Mario Tennis Open.
Why the short menu hurt the score
The game has four modes: Mega Battle, Classic Tennis, Knockback Challenge and online play. Knockback Challenge is the only structured single-player option. It's an endurance run where each win brings a tougher opponent. After that, you're replaying the same matches with different settings.
Sliva pointed to the GameCube's Mario Power Tennis, which had more characters, more modes and more varied courses a decade earlier. Nintendo World Report's Daan Koopman added three specific complaints:
- every court shares the same stadium look, even though the surfaces differ;
- online play has no option to team up with friends;
- the game has fewer features than the previous three entries.
A great core game with little around it works for a party and wears thin for anyone playing alone.
The split tells you who will enjoy it
The critics' disagreement lines up with two kinds of players. If friends come over and you want quick doubles matches, you'll spend your time on exactly what Hilliard praised. Short rallies, big smashes and a Mega Mushroom changing a game halfway through all work well with people sitting next to you.
It was also the first Mario Tennis with simultaneous worldwide online play, in either Mega Battle or Classic Tennis. It supports amiibo too: you can train a figure to play the way you do, and it can join online matches as an extra competitor. Those features give a solo player some reason to come back, but Koopman's point about missing friend pairing still applies.
If you want a career mode or an adventure to play through, the critics' complaints are the ones that will matter to you. Even Hilliard, the most generous of the four, said there was "little else to hook you in." It's also Wii U only, so it's a weak reason to keep that console set up.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20141656 wikidata.org