Undertale turns the old RPG fight into a choice about mercy
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A one-person RPG built on an old blueprint
Undertale has no series behind it. It's a 2015 role-playing game created by American indie developer Toby Fox in GameMaker. 8-4 shares the developer credit and co-published the game with Fangamer. Critics called it a spiritual successor to EarthBound, and Destructoid's Ben Davis compared its tone, characters and storytelling to Cave Story. That family tree matters, because the game borrows the shape of an older RPG and then changes what happens inside it.
The setup is simple. A child falls into the Underground, a region far beneath the Earth's surface that's sealed off by a magical barrier, and has to find a way back up. The monsters who live there may get in the way, or they may not.
What it kept from the classic RPG
- A top-down view, with towns, caves and puzzles between fights.
- Scripted and random encounters that switch to a separate battle screen.
- EXP and gold for every kill, plus a level stat the game calls LOVE.
- Timed button presses when you attack.
On paper that's a familiar loop. The game keeps it intact on purpose: it counts on players expecting to grind, and then it questions that habit.
What it changed: fights you can talk your way out of
Two changes carry the game. The first is that defending is a small bullet hell. You steer a heart that stands for your soul through each monster's attacks, and boss fights keep changing how that heart moves. Daniel Tack of Game Informer called the system "incredibly nuanced." Giant Bomb's Austin Walker found it "unconventional, clever, and occasionally really difficult." The Escapist's Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw praised how it blends turn-based and live combat.
The second is the ACT menu. Each monster responds to its own set of actions, and the right ones let you spare it. Some bosses only end peacefully if you survive until they finish talking. It's possible to finish the whole game without killing anything. IGN's Kallie Plagge singled out this option to pick a friendly conversation over a fight. Jesse Singal of The Boston Globe tied the empathy it builds to a "fundamental sweetness" at the game's core.
Every kill earns EXP and raises LOVE. It reads like a reward until the game shows you what it cost.
Choices the game remembers
Who lives and who dies changes the dialogue, the characters, the story and the ending. The game also plays with being a game. On a second playthrough, boss dialogue changes based on what you did the first time. Writing in the Journal of Popular Culture, essayist Sean Travers read Undertale as a critique of mainstream RPGs, where killing enemies earns experience points. Travers also noted how hard the Genocide route punishes players who ignore its warnings, with a darkening tone and disturbing imagery. In Games and Culture, Gabriel Elvery argued that the pacifist route works because its simple, everyday monsters invite a kind of friendship that the violent route takes away.
That memory across playthroughs is the boldest change. Replaying is normally neutral. Here, the game judges it.
Where critics pushed back: the art
The writing won near-unanimous praise. Plagge called it "consistently funny," Croshaw named it the best-written game of 2015, and PC Gamer's Richard Cobbett said even its weaker moments "just about work." The visuals split reviewers. Plagge called them "often ugly" but said the music and animation make up for it. Croshaw said they swing from functional to "just plain bad." Tack and Cobbett liked them, and a Famitsu reviewer called the pixel art amateur but original.
That's the main complaint on the record. Against it: Metacritic's "universal acclaim" rating, recommendations from 97% of critics on OpenCritic, and a critic average of 9.3, computed from those critic aggregates.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Undertale en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21039924 wikidata.org