Until Dawn won't let you take back a choice, and that's its best idea
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
No choice can be taken back on this mountain
Until Dawn is built on one rule: what happens stays done. Eight young adults have to survive on Blackwood Mountain until rescue comes at dawn, and any or all of them can die. A strict auto-save stops you from reloading an earlier file. The only ways to change a bad call are to restart, or to finish the game and start a new one. Deaths are permanent, and the story carries on without whoever was lost.
The game calls this its butterfly effect system. Choices range from picking up a book to deciding who lives, and some are on a timer. Twenty-two critical choices branch into hundreds of endings. Critics who liked the game mostly liked it for this. Jeff Marchiafava at Game Informer valued that some choices reshape the story in a big way. Game Revolution's Jessica Vazquez called not knowing the outcome until the end a "welcome limitation".
Critics split on how much the early choices matter
The rule only works if the choices carry weight, and on that point critics disagreed. Alexa Ray Corriea at GameSpot praised the "paranoia" of decisions that put a character's life on the line. Ray Corriea also liked how deep the system runs, which rewards replays with scenes a first run misses. Mollie L Patterson at Electronic Gaming Monthly called the system a "fantastic" inclusion that never reached its full potential.
The skeptics had a specific complaint. Chris Carter at Destructoid found the system "gimmicky" because the choices didn't move the plot much. GamesRadar's Louise Blain judged most choices in the first half meaningless, though Blain found the second half better. Taken together, those reviews point to a slow first half and a payoff that arrives late.
Quick time events decide who lives, for better and worse
The action is mostly quick time events, so a missed button press can be as final as a choice. Most critics thought the QTEs were handled well and helped pull players in. The standout is the "Don't Move" prompt, which asks you to hold the controller as still as possible to stay hidden. Ray Corriea picked it out for the tension it builds. Marchiafava rated it among the best uses of the idea in games because the prompts were timed and demanded precision.
The same design also drew the sharpest complaint. Polygon's Phillip Kollar respected the lack of manual saves but called the result punitive, since one slipped input can kill a character for good. Other critics found the rest of the controls rough:
- Patterson found them cumbersome and suggested the cause might be the game's start as a PlayStation Move exclusive.
- IGN's Lucy O'Brien disliked the motion controls and found some QTEs tedious.
- VentureBeat's Dean Takahashi called moving around in 3D awkward.
- Carter called the gameplay unimaginative.
Hunting for clues feeds the choices, inside narrow walls
Between the action scenes, you walk and search in a linear space from a third-person view. That searching supports the main idea. Totems give glimpses of what may happen, so you can weigh a choice before it arrives, and an in-game log keeps track of clues and secrets across playthroughs. Critics regarded these collectibles as meaningful, and they commonly praised the level design and the variety of locations.
Blain liked the quiet walking stretches and the fixed camera angles that frame the scares. Ray Corriea wanted more to do. In Ray Corriea's view, the linear layout and the few ways to interact with the surroundings wasted the setting.
A slasher film you steer, with a slasher film's script
Blain and Patterson both called the game a "love letter" to horror films, and Patterson compared it to a "B-grade teen slasher flick". Andrew Webster at The Verge said the control you have over events is what makes it "something special". The cast drew praise as well. Carter singled out Peter Stormare as the psychiatrist Dr. Hill, whose sessions between the 10 chapters speak to the player directly about their fears and choices and grow more disturbing as the game goes on. Marchiafava and Takahashi both liked how the characters grow as the story unfolds.
The case against is mostly about the writing. O'Brien argued that sticking so closely to genre tropes dulls the scares, and criticized the uneven tone. Kollar objected to "awkward cuts" and scene-hopping, and said limits in the motion capture held back the acting. Permanent choices raise the stakes, but a clumsy scene can still let the air out of them.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Until Dawn en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q7897632 wikidata.org