Analysis · Assassin's Creed Valhalla

Valhalla gives Assassin's Creed its best balance yet, at the cost of sheer bulk

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Praise for its balance, criticism for its size

The highest praise came from Game Informer, which wrote that "for the first time in the series, the balance feels perfect" across combat, exploration, story and settlement management. GamesRadar+ agreed, giving it 4.5 out of 5 stars and calling the result "a triumphant balance." The Escapist went further and called it a high point for the series in its role-playing era.

The harshest review came from GameRevolution, which gave it 2.5 out of 4 stars. It pointed to an "unnecessarily inflated hour count," limited stealth, a disconnected story and a strong sense of familiarity, and compared Valhalla to Assassin's Creed Unity as a sign of a series in decline. Most critics sided with the first group: Metacritic lists the reception as "generally favorable," and OpenCritic found that 91% of critics recommended it.

More weapons, and stealth comes back into focus

You play Eivor Varinsdottir, a Viking raider leading a clan into the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms of England between 872 and 878 AD. You can play Eivor as a woman or a man, or let the game switch between the two at key story moments. Combat adds flails and greatswords and lets you hold almost any weapon in each hand, shields included. Every piece of gear you pick up is unique.

Stealth gets more attention than in the two games before it. Eivor can hide in crowds with the hood up, play dead, send the raven Sýnin to distract guards and use a hidden blade that kills most enemies in one strike (bosses are the exception). The developers say there are 25 enemy types, and enemies can use objects around them to their advantage.

Critics disagreed about how well this works. GamesRadar+ liked having both gory combat and the "iconic hidden blade." The Escapist singled out the combat for praise. GameRevolution still called the stealth limited, and Rock, Paper, Shotgun said the game's systems didn't hang together, describing it as "daunting and messy."

A story that took risks, with thin characters

The story follows Eivor's efforts to settle in England, which pull the clan into the centuries-old conflict between the Assassin Brotherhood and the Templar Order. A present-day frame story follows Layla Hassan, who relives Eivor's memories while trying to save the Earth. Unlike earlier games that moved steadily from one region to the next, Valhalla keeps sending you back to your home settlement and to places you've already been as new leads come in. Some missions can be settled by talking instead of fighting, and your choices change who sides with you.

GameSpot gave it 8 out of 10. It liked the story and the way it wrapped up several long-running plotlines, but found the characters underdeveloped. Its summary was that the game's narrative risks pay off "as a whole." Eivor drew more consistent praise: Rock, Paper, Shotgun liked the character even in a mixed review, and Eivor was nominated at the D.I.C.E. Awards for Outstanding Achievement in Character.

Bugs, burnout and a busy in-game store

IGN also gave it 8 out of 10 and called it "a lot buggier than it should be." Hardcore Gamer liked the quality-of-life improvements over Origins and Odyssey. It also warned that players who had already finished those two long games might be burnt out on the format. Rock, Paper, Shotgun said the game is a poor first Assassin's Creed for newcomers because of how complex it is.

After launch, there was a separate complaint. In early February 2021, fans accused Ubisoft of putting microtransactions ahead of bug fixes, after a widely shared post noted that the in-game store sold nine exclusive armor sets. That's as many as the base game included.

Norwegian and Danish critics loved the setting

The setting got praise from critics close to it. NRK, Norway's national broadcaster, said the game had "by far the most beautiful representation of Norway" in any game. The Danish newspaper JydskeVestkysten praised the Danish voice cast, saying Eivor comes across as a raw, stubborn Viking without sliding into caricature. The music was also recognized: the soundtrack for the Dawn of Ragnarök expansion, composed by Stephanie Economou, won the first Grammy given for Best Score Soundtrack for Video Games and Other Interactive Media.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet