Analysis · Dragon Age: The Veilguard

Veilguard trades tactics for combos and leans on a cast critics loved

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Combat is real time now, and the combos carry it

Fights happen in real time from a third-person view. You build your character as a rogue, mage or warrior and chain abilities into combos. That replaces the slower, strategy-first approach of earlier Dragon Age games. A pause-and-play mechanism similar to Inquisition's is still there, so you can stop the action and line up your next move. You take two of seven companions into each fight, but you can't control them directly.

Critics were split on how well this works. NPR's Andy Bickerton called the action the game's strongest feature and found mastering combat and party composition "thoroughly rewarding" from start to finish. Ash Parrish of The Verge liked the combo system and the new elemental effects on weapons. She also liked that mages can switch between melee and ranged attacks, which gives fights a "kinetic, almost chaotic energy".

Others found it thinner. The Guardian's Malindy Hetfeld called the combat functional but repetitive, without much room for strategy. IGN's Leana Hafer said the boss fights were the high point, but felt companions in battle were little more than extensions of the player character. If the reason you play Dragon Age is to give orders to a full party, expect less of that here.

Portals replace the open world, and the pace picks up

Inquisition had an open world. The Veilguard uses a hub-and-spoke design instead: you reach discrete levels through magical portals, and those areas vary in size. Critics broadly enjoyed the graphics and the level design. The cost is texture. PC Gamer's Lauren Morton argued that cutting the "most common RPG frictions" can leave the game feeling "more action adventure than RPG" at times.

The front door is unusually welcoming. Bickerton pointed to the accessibility and difficulty settings as friendly to more casual players. The character creator drew praise too:

  • four lineages: human, dwarf, elf or qunari;
  • a backstory tied to one of six factions, which shapes your character's course through the game;
  • body size and body part options that don't depend on the voice or pronouns you pick, an approach IGN's Alyssa Mora praised for its "body diversity".

The companions are why most critics stayed

Polygon's Todd Harper called the companions the heart of the game, "weird and idiosyncratic in the best ways". Kazuma Hashimoto of Them said they seem like fantasy stock types at first, then open up into "mundane moments" that make them feel like normal people. Hafer called each one the star of their own story. Parrish enjoyed their banter and liked that the game now tells you clearly when you've locked into a romance.

There's real dissent. Morton found the cast short on nuance and missed any working system for disapproval or group conflict:

"Good people don't make great characters." (Lauren Morton, PC Gamer)

Oliver Brandt of Sports Illustrated saw making every companion romanceable as a small step back. He and Robin Bea of Inverse both praised Taash's story arc, which openly presents a central character as nonbinary. PC Gamer's Harvey Randall was more critical, calling the wider writing "scattershot, clumsy, and unpolished".

A sequel that keeps the past at arm's length

The Veilguard is the direct sequel to Inquisition. You play Rook, trying to stop the elven god Solas from ending the world, and you accidentally free two more elven gods along the way. Earlier games imported your full history. This one lets you set only three choices from Inquisition. Creative director John Epler said this let the team avoid contradicting what players had done before.

Bickerton called that a "letdown". IGN's Matt Purslow said the game was "at war with itself", sidelining Solas and Varric despite being a direct sequel. Hetfeld found the writing "surprisingly mediocre" and the new gods "comically evil". Solas is the thread most critics rated. Parrish praised how his arc pushed her toward a choice she hadn't expected to make. Reviewers were also divided on how much your choices matter, and some found the big decisions "few and far between".

For replay value, look to the cast and the setup rather than branching plots. Seven companions with room for two per fight, six faction backstories and three classes give a second run something new. Don't expect the story to turn out very differently.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet