Analysis · Warhammer: Vermintide 2

Vermintide 2's melee won critics over, but its loot system split them

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the fighting and split on the loot

Critics agreed about the combat. They disagreed about what comes after a mission ends. Steven Messner of PC Gamer called the melee combat and level design "feverishly fun", but he faulted the matchmaking and found the RPG progression systems confusing. Destructoid saw that same layer as a strength and listed "an addictive loot system" among the sequel's gains. Dominic Sheard of DarkZero praised its "more rewarding loot progression" compared with the first game.

The system they're arguing about is easy to describe. After each mission, rewards come from a randomized loot system. Each of the five characters splits into careers, 15 in the base game and 20 with DLC, and every career has its own skills and abilities. Some critics saw a long list of builds to explore. Others saw a menu that gets in the way of the next fight.

What the split tells you about your own taste

The two camps want different things from a co-op game. If you like gear that keeps getting a little better, a career you tweak between runs, and a reason to replay a mission you've already beaten, you're the player Destructoid and DarkZero were writing for. To them, the loot loop is what holds the game together.

If you want to drop in, cut through rat-men for a mission or two and log off, Messner's complaints matter more. Unclear progression is easier to live with when the fighting is this good, but poor matchmaking hurts a game built around co-op. Solo players who rely on finding strangers should take that warning seriously. A regular group of friends avoids most of the problem.

The parts nobody argued about

Outside the progression debate, critics mostly agreed:

  • Melee with weight. Sheard praised how heavy and satisfying the hits feel. IGN's Tom Marks joked his way through praise for the creative ways players can take the "ratmen" apart.
  • Levels worth replaying. Destructoid singled out "beautifully designed sprawling levels", and Sheard pointed to better level design and more varied environments.
  • More to fight. The Chaos army joins the Skaven, the game has over 20 enemy types, and DarkZero found the boss fights better than the first game's.

PC Gamer named it the best cooperative game of 2018. Sheard argued that the sequel had built an identity beyond its Left 4 Dead inspirations and called it "the cooperative game to own on PC for 2018."

How much game you get, and what it costs you

The base game has 13 missions, over 20 enemy types and over 50 weapons. The first number is the one to watch. Thirteen missions isn't many for a game you replay, so how long it lasts depends on whether the loot and careers keep you coming back. That brings it back to the same argument.

Marks also praised the game for having no microtransactions and compared it favorably with Star Wars: Battlefront II on that front. The game is rated Mature 17+, which fits all the dismemberment the critics enjoyed.

Aggregate scores are consistent: 83 out of 100 on the Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Windows versions, 85 out of 100 on another aggregate, and 92% on a third. Those feed the critic average of 8.4, which comes from the critic scores and isn't a separate verdict. In November 2025, Fatshark said the game had passed 25 million lifetime players, a count that includes people who got it free during a promotion.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet