Analysis · Mount & Blade: Warband

Warband trades polish for a medieval sandbox you conquer on your own terms

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want to write their own war

Warband is for a particular kind of player: one who would rather build a reputation in a medieval world than follow a quest line through it. It drops a custom character into the land of Calradia with no set objectives. Then it leaves you to decide whether to fight bandits, serve a lord or take a castle for yourself.

The loop is simple to describe. You travel the overworld map by pointing and clicking. When your party runs into another one, the game switches to real-time battle. Wins earn renown, and enough renown opens the bigger options: working for lords, holding fiefs, attacking towns and hiring more soldiers. Companions found across the map add abilities to your warband. The common long-term goal is conquering all of Calradia, but nothing forces it.

Where the sandbox pays off

For that player, Warband delivers. TaleWorlds layered politics onto the first game. You can now influence lords, marry ladies and, if you aren't sworn to anyone, capture a town or castle and found your own faction. A sixth faction, the Sarranid Sultanate, joined the map, and the overworld was reorganized.

Combat rewards attention. Melee works on four attack directions (up, down, left and right) with four matching blocks, so a fight is about reading your opponent rather than mashing a button.

Critics consistently called it a low-cost game with more replay value and longevity than many studio releases of its day. Bob Byrne at Black Gate summed up the appeal as first-person combat plus large-scale troop management, and he called it close to the most enjoyable game he'd played, even without a set endgame.

The more you want to set your own goals, the more Warband gives back. The more you want the game to set them, the less it has to offer.

Multiplayer is the main reason to own it

Reviewers agreed the new multiplayer mode was the headline. ComputerGames.ro called it "exactly what its predecessor was missing," and Nick Kolan of IGN said it was "arguably the main reason" the expansion exists. Mod DB named it Best Multiplayer Indie Game of 2010 in its Editor's Choice awards.

Online play strips out the map and role-playing systems and keeps the fighting. Players pick from balanced Archery, Cavalry and Infantry templates and buy better gear with denars earned in matches. Eight modes shipped at launch, most borrowed from shooters, like team battles and capture the flag, alongside castle sieges from the main game. Matches are designed for up to 200 players.

The catches came from the same reviews:

  • Critics noted only a few maps and modes, and imbalance in several of them.
  • Alex Yue of Gamer Limit and Christopher Rick of Gamers Daily News found few servers running at any one time, and those weren't always full.
  • Kolan, on the other hand, found the community friendlier than in other multiplayer games.

Where it falls short

The single-player side got the least new work. Brett Todd of GameSpot said that even with the new faction and political quests, it lacks the depth and background of other role-playing games. He also warned that the open world and steep learning curve may put some players off.

The visuals improved on the original but still looked old to critics. IGN said Warband looked like it came out "a decade ago," and Todd found a few "picturesque" scenes among generally dated graphics. Rick was the outlier: he argued that how it plays matters more than how it looks.

Several critics also felt calling it a sequel overreached, since it plays like an improved version of Mount & Blade. Yue went further and said owners of the original who don't care about multiplayer should pass on it. Platform matters too: according to Metacritic, the PC version drew generally favorable reviews, while the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions landed in mixed or average territory.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet