Analysis · Wartales

Wartales turns a broke mercenary band into a deep tactics sandbox

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Deep under a drab coat

The best praise Wartales got came from PC Gamer, which told readers not to be put off by its "drab exterior" and called it a "richly rewarding" exercise in building a party. The harshest line came from NME. It said the game strays far enough from the usual path to be interesting but isn't "bold or elegant enough to be essential."

Both can be true, and the rest of the reviews explain why. Shiro Games built a tactical role-playing game in which you run a band of mercenaries through a low fantasy land recovering from a plague. Food is short, bandits are everywhere, and your company has to pay its own way. Critic aggregates landed at 77/100 across 17 reviews and 71% across 19, which gives a critic average of 7.7 out of 10.

There is no main quest, on purpose

Wartales gives you an overworld map dotted with towns, dungeons and rival mercenaries, then leaves the route to you. Each region has its own storyline to follow and narrative choices to make, but nothing ties them into a single plot. The pressure comes from money instead. The game plays partly like an economic simulation in which you keep finding ways to fund a growing company.

Rock Paper Shotgun liked the result but still wished for a main quest to give the game more momentum, while admitting that request cuts against how the game is built. That tension sits at the center of Wartales. Players who set their own goals will find plenty to chase. Players who need a story to pull them forward may drift.

Difficulty works the same way. With level scaling off, regions get harder the farther you travel, so the map itself sets the pace. You can switch scaling on if you'd rather go anywhere without hitting a wall.

Camp chores that turn into anecdotes

The survival layer is where Wartales earns its strongest reviews. Your mercenaries tire as they travel and have to camp once they're exhausted. If they aren't fed while camping, some may desert. At camp, each one works at a profession:

  • cooking raw food into meals that keep the crew loyal,
  • blacksmithing gear from gathered materials,
  • appraising relics picked up on the road,
  • turning resources like leather into clothing.

When the band meets hostile people or animals, the fight moves to a turn-based tactical map. Rock Paper Shotgun compared the game to Rimworld and Dwarf Fortress and praised how its mechanics interact to produce memorable stories. The outlet also credited the long early access period, starting with the first Windows release on December 1, 2021, for sharpening those systems.

The game's best moments aren't scripted. They come from a hungry crew, a long road and a fight nobody planned.

Where the loop wears thin

NME welcomed a hardcore RPG at a time when the genre has fallen out of favor, saying games like this are "worth their weight in looted gold." It still found the mechanics repetitive once you've worked through several regions, and it called the art style conservative. That fits PC Gamer's warning about the plain look: even the game's fans admitted it doesn't impress on sight.

The repetition complaint follows from the design. With no overarching story, the late game is more of the same loop with bigger numbers and tougher regions. That suits players who enjoy tuning a company. Players who want each new region to bring something new may tire of it.

The game has kept growing. Shiro Games announced in November 2024 that it had sold more than one million copies, and the "Skelmar Invasion" expansion added siege battles and more content on December 10, 2024. It runs on Windows, Nintendo Switch and Xbox Series X and Series S, supports co-op, and is rated Mature 17+.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet