Watch Dogs 2 is at its best when the hacker leaves the gun at home
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A hacker with a phone against a watched city
The pitch is simple. Marcus Holloway, a young hacker, joins the group DedSec to take down ctOS, the surveillance system that runs the San Francisco Bay Area. His main tool is his smartphone, and the city is full of things it can reach.
Critics kept coming back to that idea. Game Informer's Elise Favis liked that hacking came first in the design, and Destructoid's Zack Furniss praised how many uses it had. The best test of each part of Watch Dogs 2 is whether it supports a hacker beating a system with code or drifts back toward a standard shooter.
The phone does more than most open-world guns
The hacking toolkit is wide. Marcus can:
- take direct control of a car, or send it crashing in a random direction
- change traffic lights and jam up the streets
- tap security cameras and every mobile phone in the game
- rewrite a stranger's personal records so police arrest them or a gang such as the Tezcas or the Bratva attacks them
- trigger a "mass hack" that hits a crowd's electronics at once
The environment is part of the toolkit too. An air conditioning unit can be rigged to shock a guard who walks past. A quadcopter and a remote-control car let Marcus scout and hack from a distance, gear the first game's Aiden Pearce never had.
Furniss saw that the system works best without killing anyone. The taser can stun enemies, and upgrades are split into Ghost, Aggressor and Trickster paths, so the game supports a quiet style through to the end.
Where the guns break the idea
This is where the core idea strains. Marcus can also carry guns he makes with a printer, plus explosives such as mines, and critics found that hard to square with who he's supposed to be.
Polygon's Philip Kollar called the firearms "a complete failure of imagination" for a group of peaceful hacktivists.
Furniss went further and suggested the guns could have been cut entirely. IGN's Dan Stapleton pointed out that Marcus's strong moral streak sits awkwardly beside the option to kill bystanders, and EGM's Matt Buchholtz said murder made little sense for this character. Favis also noticed a gap between Marcus's personality and his actions.
Several reviewers ended up in the same place, though: the clash pushed them toward stealth, which Stapleton called the best-supported approach. So the weakness has a workaround. Ignore the arsenal and the game holds together.
A smaller-feeling Bay Area that's twice as big
The map covers San Francisco, Oakland, Marin County and Silicon Valley, more than twice the size of the first game's Chicagoland. Kollar called its spaces "cleverly designed" and said it never felt overwhelming, partly because all of it is open from the start.
Getting around got better too. Critics called the overhauled driving an improvement, with Favis describing it as "smoother", and Marcus now has parkour moves on foot. Buchholtz said side tasks that raise DedSec's follower count did a good job of pulling players into the city. There are also more than 700 pieces of clothing, sold in shops that match the style of each area.
Funnier than the first game, rougher round the edges
The tone changed the most. Furniss praised the move away from the first game's seriousness, and Kollar said the jokey tone suits hacker culture. Stapleton liked Marcus more than Aiden Pearce and liked the DedSec crew too. Favis disagreed on the crew, calling the supporting characters "too obnoxious and petty" to care about.
The technical problems were real. Critics reported glitches and low frame rates on consoles, Favis among them on PlayStation 4, though Update 1.04 later fixed the console issues. VideoGamer's Alice Bell mentioned multiplayer problems but still called joining DedSec "a riot and a half".
Sources
- Wikipedia: Watch Dogs 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24455756 wikidata.org