Analysis · Watch Dogs

Watch Dogs makes Chicago hackable, but its hacker never comes alive

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The phone does more work than the guns

Most of Watch Dogs happens through Aiden Pearce's smartphone. From a third-person view, you can switch traffic lights, steer trains, break into security systems, jam cellphones and pull up a passerby's private details, down to emptying their bank account. Getting into bigger systems means solving short hacking puzzles.

The phone also feeds the combat. Aiden carries an extendable baton for melee and an arsenal that runs from handguns and shotguns to sniper rifles, machine guns and grenade launchers. He can slow time while aiming, plant proximity IEDs, throw grenades and set electronic lures. Missions can go lethal or not.

Critics liked this mix more than any other part of the game. Jeff Marchiafava wrote in Game Informer that hacking gave the fighting meaning and that the shooting made full firefights "enjoyable". IGN's Dan Stapleton said the cover-based gunplay "feels good", and Polygon's Arthur Gies credited the cover system with making stealth work as well. PC Gamer's Christopher Livingston named hacking as the best feature. The main dissent came from Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead, who called the puzzles "tired old PipeMania-style" filler.

A fake Chicago built to be busy

The open world is a loose copy of the Chicago area in 2013, split into six regions: Parker Square, the Loop, Brandon Docks, the Wards, Mad Mile and a small rural town called Pawnee. A day-night cycle and changing weather alter how people on the street behave. You can climb walls, hack forklifts and lifts to reach high spots, and drive motorcycles, muscle cars, SUVs, sports cars and speedboats. Whitehead found the driving "slick and intuitive".

Around the main missions sit the usual open-world layers:

  • a reputation system that rises when you stop crimes and drops when you commit them, which even changes whether a carjacked driver calls the police;
  • a skill tree fed by hacking, combat, driving and crafting;
  • ctOS towers that reveal map icons and side missions;
  • minigames ranging from shooting aliens to piloting a giant robot spider;
  • QR codes and audio logs to collect.

Opinions split here. Destructoid's Chris Carter said the extras were his favorite part, and GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd also praised the side content. Tom Watson, writing in New Statesman, found the pile of side tasks dull and the whole thing derivative of Grand Theft Auto V.

The revenge plot is the weak link

The story follows Aiden, a grey hat hacker hunting the people behind a botched hit that killed his niece. Critics rarely agreed this broadly on anything else in the game, and they agreed it didn't work.

Carter called the characters "lifeless" and the plot predictable. Whitehead rated the story and its lead as the weakest parts and said the script ducked the moral questions its premise raised. VanOrd made a similar point about the game's take on technology, and said the story only improved when it dropped its revenge clichés. GamesRadar's Andy Hartup called Aiden "a bit of a dullard", while Stapleton, Livingston and VanOrd all preferred the supporting cast to the hero. Gies said the plot "struggles to remain coherent" after a decent start.

Hartup's advice is the useful one: take the narrative piecemeal, mission by mission, rather than as a whole.

The graphics debate and how long it lasts

Watch Dogs won a pile of awards and nominations after its E3 2012 reveal, and that hype shaped how its looks were judged. Ubisoft faced accusations of a graphical downgrade once 2014 footage was compared with the 2012 demo. Carter and Marchiafava both said the finished game looked worse than its early videos. Whitehead and Stapleton still praised the visuals, with Stapleton singling out the "intricately detailed" map.

Multiplayer adds the most staying power. Up to eight players can share the city for hacking contracts and races. Other players can also slip into your game disguised as ordinary pedestrians and hack you, leaving you to find them in the crowd. You can turn these invasions off, but doing so resets your multiplayer rank to zero. On PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, free-roam with other players and the four-on-four decryption mode were cut.

VideoGamer.com's Steven Burns described it well: undoubtedly enjoyable, but unlikely to stick in the memory.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet