Analysis · Wii Fit U

Wii Fit U puts friendliness ahead of hard training

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A fitness game built to be friendly first

Wii Fit U rests on one idea: exercise goes down easier when it feels like a game and never scolds you. One review quoted on Metacritic called it "friendly" and said it isn't as hardcore as some fitness buffs would like. That sums up both the appeal and the limit.

Most critics thought the approach worked. It holds a 72 out of 100 from 19 critics on Metacritic, and US Gamer gave it 4.5 out of 5, saying its Nintendo charm keeps it "never demoralizing". PC Magazine rated it 4 out of 5 and called it a worthy sequel and a useful fitness tool. OpenCritic shows a more mixed picture: only 54% of critics recommend it.

The balance board still does most of the work

As in Wii Fit and Wii Fit Plus, you stand on the Wii Balance Board, which measures your weight and center of balance while you do yoga, strength training and the rest. Wii Fit U is the only game on the Wii U that supports the board, so it's the board's last reason to stay plugged in.

The new hardware fits the friendly idea:

  • The Fit Meter is an activity meter (a pedometer) that comes in every retail box. You carry it while jogging or moving around, and it sends its data to the Wii U over infrared when you hold it near the GamePad.
  • The GamePad joins some activities and can serve as the only screen, so the TV stays free. A foldable stand for it is included.
  • Effort ratings sort exercises by category and by how hard they are, each given a number, so you can pick a level that suits you.

Owners of the earlier games can transfer all their save data, so their history comes with them. The New York Times called the setup efficient, unobtrusive and motivating, and said it's "cheaper than joining a gym".

The new activities lean toward play

Most of the additions are about fun, not strain. There's a whole dance section, from Beginner Dance through Hula, Jazz, Hip-Hop, Locking, Flamenco and Salsa. There are also new games: Free Boxing, Rowing Crew, Core Luge, Scuba Search, Climbing, Trampoline Target, Hosedown and an Ultimate Obstacle Course. Lifewire praised the "clever new mini-games" and a better routine setup than the original Wii Fit had.

The trade is that eight Wii Fit Plus activities were cut, including Snowboard Slalom, Penguin Slide, Skateboard Arena, Tightrope Tension and Lotus Focus. The regular and Plus versions of Table Tilt, Balance Bubble and Basic Run were merged into single entries. US Gamer said the balance exercises are the most game-like part of the package, so the cut balance games matter more than the list length suggests.

Where light turns into too light

This is where critics split. Nintendo World Report praised its customizable routines and the motivation it got from the online community. Polygon called it "too light-weight to be a contender" as real exercise. A study backs Polygon on intensity: it found Wii Fit U suits moderate exercise and conditioning, not intensive workouts, and that whether its exercises improve fitness is unknown.

The gentleness does have a use beyond the living room. Unlike the original Wii Fit, Wii Fit U has been used in physical therapy. The CDC has used games with light to moderate activity to help patients recover from brain damage, and research found users felt better balance and upper-body movement.

Gentle enough for rehab, too gentle for training: who this game suits comes down to which of those you need.

One caveat about that community: much of the social motivation critics liked ran through Miiverse, Nintendo's social network, which has since shut down. Anyone starting now gets the routines without the community around them.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet