Analysis · Wii Sports Club

Wii Sports Club sharpens the swing but stumbles once it goes online

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A familiar game rebuilt around finer motion

Wii Sports Club remakes the five sports from the 2006 Wii launch title in HD for the Wii U: tennis, baseball, bowling, golf and boxing. Critics saw it as a bet on one idea. It keeps the same swing-the-remote sports, makes them more precise with the Wii Remote Plus, and adds online opponents. The rest of the package either supports that idea or works against it.

Reviewers mostly liked the first half. GameSpot's Heidi Kemps preferred the more complex motion controls and the way they changed play compared with the original. IGN's Scott Thompson was impressed by the same thing and surprised by how much the controls had improved since Wii Sports Resort. The second half, online play, got a much rougher reception.

The aggregate scores show that split. Metacritic gave it 68/100 from 22 reviews, which falls in its "mixed or average reviews" band, and on OpenCritic only 25% of critics recommended it. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 6.6 out of 10.

Golf and tennis prove the point, boxing doesn't

Sport by sport, the precision idea mostly held up:

  • Golf. You set the GamePad on the floor, where it shows a ball to aim at and hit. Critics said this was the most accurate copy of a real sport in the game, and Nintendo World Report called golf the best sport here for that reason. Kemps raised a fair concern that a controller on the floor can get damaged.
  • Tennis. Critics praised its precise controls, and its return mattered because it had been left out of Wii Sports Resort.
  • Baseball. You aim and pitch at the batter on the GamePad. Thompson described a "sort-of augmented reality" feel (IGN).
  • Bowling. Thompson liked its precision, but Nintendo World Report was disappointed that it doesn't use the GamePad.
  • Boxing. The Nunchuk is gone, and you hold one or two Wii Remote Plus controllers instead. Critics found the controls more precise but still unintuitive, and they again ranked boxing as the weakest sport.

Each sport also has side modes, such as whack-a-mole with tennis controls and bingo played by hitting golf balls. Kemps called them "a nice distraction" (GameSpot), which is fair praise but small.

Online play adds rivals and a lot of waiting

Online play is the biggest change from the original. All five sports can be played online. Tennis, baseball and boxing run in real time, while bowling and golf are turn-based. Players join a regional club, clubs compete against each other, and the rankings and stats live on Miiverse. During a match you can send preset messages and GamePad drawings through a feature called Online Banter.

Critics welcomed the idea but not how it worked. Kemps pointed to real-time lag, a clumsy matchmaking process and restrictive options that left little variety between matches. Thompson's complaint was pace. In bowling and golf he spent much of each match waiting, often because he was paired with a much weaker player.

Thompson said almost every online match seemed to include "someone who skipped the tutorial" (IGN).

The real-time sports did better, and critics said tennis and baseball held up much better online. That means the online mode works best in the same sports where the precision idea works best.

Paying by the sport

Wii Sports Club wasn't sold as a single package. The first time you played a sport, you got it free for 24 hours, and after that you had to pay. A gold pass cost $10 and unlocked one sport for good. A day pass cost $2 and opened every sport for 24 hours.

This model suits a game whose sports vary this much in quality. If you only want golf and tennis, the two sports critics rated highest, buy those two gold passes and skip the rest. If you're hosting a group for one evening, the day pass is the cheaper choice. Paying to own boxing is hard to justify, since critics ranked it the weakest sport here and in the original.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet