Analysis · Wolverine

Wolverine bets everything on brutal melee and runs out of new moves

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One idea: a tight, linear game about a man and his claws

Marvel's Wolverine is built on a narrow promise. It's a focused, linear action game, and nearly everything in it runs through Logan's close-range fighting. Push Square's Liam Croft called it a "linear and focused experience." Game Informer's Matt Miller compared its "taut, tightly animated combat" to God of War and Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order. That narrow focus is the game's best decision, and for many critics it's also what holds it back.

Insomniac Games made it as a standalone entry that shares continuity with its Spider-Man games. Logan, an amnesiac mutant, rejoins his old unit, Team X, to investigate the abduction of displaced mutants by industrialist Bolivar Trask and the Reavers militia. Along the way he's looking for answers about his own past.

The fighting hits hard, then keeps hitting the same way

The combat lives up to the promise at first. Critics praised the same handful of things:

  • Speed and gore. Push Square singled out the fast-paced, bloody fights, brutal takedowns and team combos.
  • Feel. Shacknews's Donovan Erskine called the melee satisfying, and GameSpot's Tamoor Hussain called it solid.
  • Flexibility. Shacknews also credited the modular difficulty settings, which let players tune the challenge.

The problem is staying power. IGN's Simon Cardy found the combat "wears thin well before its conclusion." GameSpot said it lacks weight, flow and challenge and doesn't do much beyond the basics. Keith Stuart at The Guardian said some of it feels "like a chore," and Shacknews listed repetition as a con.

If the fighting is what you're buying it for, critics broadly agree it delivers early on. If you need it to stay fresh across the whole campaign, most of them say it won't.

Logan works better than the story around him

The character is the one part nearly every critic praised. Eurogamer's Chris Tapsell called Wolverine's characterization "a bright spot." The Guardian said Liam McIntyre realizes Logan well and praised the character art. Both McIntyre and Troy Baker were nominated for performance awards at the 2026 Golden Joystick Awards.

The story around Logan drew much harsher reviews. GamesRadar+'s Leon Hurley called it messy. Push Square found it relatively uninteresting, with some parts badly presented. Shacknews said it doesn't reach its potential, and The Guardian pointed to lapses in its narrative and emotional arcs. GameSpot was the exception and called the story compelling.

Video Games Chronicle's Jordan Middler made the sharpest point: the game fails to capture the character's spirit the way Insomniac did with Spider-Man. That's an important judgment for a game built so tightly around one character.

A focused design that often reads as dated

A linear structure keeps the game moving, but several critics felt it pinned the game to an older era. Middler called it "a game out of time" with dated quest design. Tapsell called it an "old-school romp" that shows how far action games have moved on. Push Square complained about restrictive invisible walls, and Shacknews found little worth doing outside combat.

The presentation gets close to universal praise. Critics cited:

  • visuals that Video Games Chronicle called best in class and Push Square called outstanding at times
  • cinematic set pieces and snappy loading and scene transitions, according to Shacknews
  • a good variety of locations, according to Push Square

The scores reflect the split. The game sits at 76/100, Metacritic rates its reviews "generally favorable," and OpenCritic found that 66% of critics recommended it. That works out to a critic average of 7.6, computed from critic aggregates. Critics received it less warmly than Insomniac's games from the decade before.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet