Analysis · Mario Golf: World Tour

World Tour shines online but its Castle Club story mode runs short

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A great teacher with a thin story mode

The best praise for Mario Golf: World Tour came from IGN, which scored it 8.6 and said you don't need to be a hardcore golf fan to get hooked. The outlet called it "a great teacher" that rewards good play and gives you plenty to do.

The sharpest complaint was about Castle Club, the story mode. Many critics said it was too short, and they disliked that Mii characters are the only playable characters in it. That leaves a lopsided game: well-liked golf and online play, with a single-player mode that critics found lacking.

Reviews were generally favorable, and the game holds an average score of 78 on Metacritic. That fits what the reviews actually say: a good game with one clear weak spot.

Arcade golf that keeps the pace up

Camelot Software Planning went for arcade golf over simulation. The goal is the usual one: get the ball into the hole in as few strokes as you can. The controls are kept simple, and play moves faster than a realistic golf game would.

The courses come in two kinds. Some are modeled on real-life courses, and others are Super Mario themed. The cast is drawn from the Mario franchise.

The most strategic part is the Super Shot. When you choose one, it adds extra distance to a hit, but you only get a limited number per course. Spending one early means you won't have it later, so every course turns into a small resource-management puzzle on top of the golf.

Online play is the main event

World Tour is the first Mario Golf game with online multiplayer, and critics rated that as one of its strongest features. It runs online golf tournaments and lets you find other players to play a round with.

Destructoid gave the game 8.5 and praised the online multiplayer in particular. Across reviews, the online side was singled out alongside the core gameplay as the main reason to pick it up.

That matters for how long the game lasts. A short story mode runs out, but tournaments and matches against other players keep going as long as you want to keep playing.

Castle Club needed more holes and more faces

The criticism of Castle Club came up across many reviews and had two parts:

  • Length. Critics found the story mode short.
  • Characters. In Castle Club you can only play as a Mii, so the Mario cast that fills the rest of the game is out of reach there.

For a series built around Mario characters, losing them in the main solo mode is a strange choice, and reviewers noticed. Anyone buying the game mostly to play alone should expect less here than the rest of the package suggests.

Easy to start, slower to master

Critics didn't fully agree on how approachable the game is. IGN saw it as a game that teaches well and hooks people who aren't golf fans. Destructoid, while still positive, said the learning curve is steep and criticized the camera and the aiming controls.

Both views can hold at once. The simple controls get you hitting the ball right away, but sinking shots reliably, and lining them up with a camera Destructoid found awkward, takes practice. Expect a few frustrating holes before the game starts to reward you.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet